IS a diet without meat the solution to the ongoing climate crisis? Some scientists are skeptical, largely because of the lack of data and analysis coming from low- and middle-income countries. While adopting a meatless diet might be pertinent in industrialized nations, it could be detrimental to Africa's economic and environmental welfare.
Meat production has been the subject of numerous concerns for the past few years, especially in Europe and the USA, because of its negative impact on the environment. Scientists from the International Center for Tropical Agriculture (ICTA) have been studying the issue and posit that it's not the only major problem. They also suggest that a meat-free diet is not a global solution to the climate crisis, and that it could even harm certain countries.
This study, published in Environmental Research Letters, shows that a no-meat diet would not have the same impact in Western, industrialized nations and in low- and middle-income countries. This research also highlights the lack of data concerning Africa. Only 13% of all scientific literature about livestock published since 1945 covered Africa, while the continent is home to 20%, 27% and 32% of global cattle, sheep and goat populations.
The ICTA scientists also note that eight out of the ten most respected institutes researching livestock are located in the USA, France, the UK and The Netherlands, while only two are headquartered in Africa. "Conclusions drawn in widely publicized reports argue that a main solution to the climate and human health crisis globally is to eat no or little meat but they are biased towards industrialized, Western systems," said Birthe Paul, lead author of the study.
Focus on solutions that have a stronger impact
In their report, the scientists also argue that only focusing on the negative effects of livestock on the environment leads to overlooking its positive role in ecosystem services, income and provisions supply in low- and middle-income countries. Such a focus also fails to take into account more systemic questions concerning the way animals are raised.
"Mixed systems in low- and middle-income countries, where animal production is fully linked with crop production, can actually be more environmentally sustainable," said one of the scientists. "In sub-Saharan Africa, manure is a nutrient resource which maintains soil health and crop productivity; while in Europe, huge amounts of manure made available through industrialized livestock production are overfertilizing agricultural land and causing environmental problems," added one of the authors of the study.
The research team concluded that a plant-based diet could be relevant in industrialized countries but that it is far from being a global answer to global warming, and especially, that it can't be applied the same way in every country.
Their study also suggests solutions that could have a stronger impact on the planet and would benefit both farmers and the environment. For instance, improved animal feed to limit greenhouse gases, better management of grazing land, and mixing crop and livestock where manure is plowed back into the soil.
The authors also note that according to Food and Agriculture Organization predictions, meat consumption in sub-Saharan Africa could reach an average of 12.9 kilograms per capita in 2028, while it could skyrocket to over 100 kilograms per capita in the USA.
AFP RELAXNEWS
Wed Dec 23 2020
While meat production can have a negative impact on industrialised countries, it plays a key economic and environmental role in Africa. AFPRelaxpic
Majikan tipu pekerja asing di Pengerang gagal bayar tunggakan gaji, berdepan pendakwaan
Majikan yang didakwa melakukan penipuan terhadap pekerja asing di Pengerang, Johor, didapati masih tidak membuat sebarang pembayaran gaji.
MediaTek umum cip Dimensity 8250 dengan teknologi 4nm
Dimensity 8250 dilengkapi lapan teras CPU dengan konfigurasi 1 x Arm Cortex-A78 3.1GHz, 3 x Arm Cortex-A78 3.0GHz dan 4 x Arm Cortex-A55 2.0GHz.
Xi, Putin hadir rasmikan Tahun Budaya China-Rusia
Xi berkata hubungan China-Rusia dalam tiga perempat abad lalu memperlihatkan pengukuhan dan pengembangan persahabatan sesama jiran.
Serangan balai polis Ulu Tiram: Bedah siasat dua mangsa, suspek sedang dijalankan
Tinjauan mendapati laluan serta pekarangan Jabatan Perubatan Forensik, HSI dikawal ketat anggota polis.
Empat individu termasuk wanita Vietnam ditahan terlibat sindiket pinjaman tanpa lesen
Selain wanita warga asing, turut ditahan tiga lelaki tempatan berusia 22 hingga 34 tahun.
Insiden Balai Polis Ulu Tiram: Jangan kongsi maklumat tidak pasti - Fahmi
Orang ramai perlu mendapatkan maklumat daripada sumber yang sah bagi memastikan mereka tidak menyebarkan maklumat yang tidak betul.
Jemaah Islamiyah ancaman utama keselamatan Asia Tenggara
JI terkenal kerana terlibat dalam beberapa serangan pengganas besar di rantau ini, termasuk pengeboman kelab malam Bali pada 2002 yang mengorbankan 202 nyawa, kebanyakannya pelancong asing.
Agenda AWANI: Mentakrifkan semula kejayaan
Apakah strategi Yayasan Peneraju dalam memperkasa dan meningkatkan penyertaan Bumiputera dalam penciptaan nilai dan penguasaan ekonomi dalam sektor baharu?
Diskusi dan analisis dalam Agenda Awani jam 9:00 malam ini.
Diskusi dan analisis dalam Agenda Awani jam 9:00 malam ini.
Huawei perkenal inovasi terbaharu WATCH FIT 3, Matebook X Pro
Boleh dipadankan dengan kedua-dua peranti iOS dan Android serta bateri yang mampu bertahan sehingga 10 hari, HUAWEI WATCH FIT 3 memastikan pemakai kekal berhubung dengan lancar.
Maszlee cadang Chong Wei bantu kembangkan bakat pemain badminton Rusia
Pengerusi IAIS Malaysia, Profesor Maszlee Malik, berhasrat menggunakan kepada kepakaran seperti Datuk Lee Chong Wei untuk membantu menggilap bakat badminton di Rusia.
COVID-19: Belanda lanjut tempoh sekatan hingga 20 April
Perintah berkurung akan dilaksanakan dari 10 malam hingga 4.30 pagi bermula 31 Mac.
AS sekat import minyak sawit FGV? Tidak beri impak signifikan kepada industri Malaysia
India dan China masih lagi menjadi pengimport terbesar minyak kelapa sawit dengan 200,000 hingga 300,000 sebulan.
MH17: Pihak pembelaan dibenar siasat mungkin ada penjelasan lain pesawat ditembak jatuh
Mahkamah membenarkan permohonan daripada peguam bela suspek, Oleg Pulatov untuk satu siasatan bagi mendapatkan penerangan daripada lebih ramai saksi.
PKP: Panduan pembelajaran komprehensif perlu dibekalkan kepada ibu bapa
Sebanyak 48 peratus pelajar di negara ini tidak mempunyai akses komputer di rumah untuk tujuan pembelajaran.
COVID-19: Angka korban hampiri 3,500, jumlah jangkitan melebihi 100,000
Negara yang mempunyai bilangan mangsa paling tinggi setakat ini ialah Korea Utara, Itali, Iran dan juga China.
Masa terbaik perkemas pasak ekonomi
Apa yang perlu dilakukan oleh Malaysia bagi memperkemas pasak ekonominya?
COVID-19: Enam penumpang kapal persiaran disahkan negatif, dibenarkan pulang
Enam penumpang kapal persiaran mewah MS Westerdam yang terdiri daripada empat warga Amerika Syarikat dan dua warga Netherlands disahkan negatif COVID-19.
Tiga cedera dalam insiden tikaman di The Hague
Seorang jurucakap polis Belanda berkata, terlalu awal untuk mengenal pasti motif serangan di The Hague itu.
Berzat tinggi, kenapa tidak didik rakyat Malaysia makan kelapa sawit? - Pakar ekonomi
Sudah tiba masanya untuk Malaysia bertindak bagi menangkis serangan terhadap industri kelapa sawit negara susulan keputusan Parlimen Eropah di Strasbourg, Perancis.
Debar sepak mula makin terasa, semangat #webelangtogether kian membara
Penyokong Malaysia dan Thailand mula membanjiri Stadium Nasional Bukit Jalil bagi menyaksikan pertemuan separuh akhir pertama Kejohanan Bola Sepak Piala AFF Suzuki 2018 malam ini.