IN times of crisis, millionaires’ voices seem to get even more attention from world governments than they usually do. The rich’s ability to direct policies has increased inequality.
We must rethink how we implement our fiscal policy to address this problem.
The World Economic Forum (WEF), held last month in Davos, Switzerland, is an example. This annual meeting was back to present famous figures from both government and private circles. WEF chose “History at a Turning Point” as a theme, with the hope that policymakers could join forces to overcome economic turbulence and political tension due to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
But this prestigious forum, launched in 1974, is not without critics. WEF has often been considered too exclusive and more of a friendly platform for millionaires and world politicians that makes their views comparable to those of the world economists’. This year is no different.
[Policymakers become nervous] when millionaires and entrepreneurs speak about the dangers of a global recession, unemployment and political instability. As a response, various incentives flowed heavily from the government’s pockets to the business world to survive during the pandemic.
Ironically, the support for businesses happens against the backdrop of increasing income inequality.
In Indonesia, millionaires’ total wealth rose by 57.9% during the pandemic, from US$57 billion to US$90 billion (Rp 847 trillion to Rp 1,337 trillion).
At the same time, 2.1 million people fell into extreme poverty. Indonesia’s Central Statistics Agency reported that the total number of poor people in Indonesia reached 9.71% or equal to 26.50 million people.
Concerns regarding increasing economic inequality have been the main focus of economic research over the past few years. These includes works by world-renowned economists Thomas Piketty, Joseph Stiglitz and Facundo Alvaredo.
One of the key messages from their research is the downward trend in tax rates for the rich, which results in greater inequality. Besides, the wealthy population and their companies benefit significantly from the low tax rates and tax amnesty, including the chance to avoid tax with legal or illegal means.
In Indonesia’s context, evidence shows that tax burdens are not distributed equally. The income tax rates of individuals in Indonesia are still considered low. The highest rate of 35% is mandatory for individual taxpayers, which is still below China, India and most of Europe.
Another challenge is that indirect taxes, such as Value Added Tax (VAT), still dominate Indonesia’s tax revenues. VAT rates applied in Indonesia are not set according to each individual’s different needs and financial capabilities. As a result, low-income families have to bear a more significant tax burden than the rich.
Meanwhile, taxation amounts primarily come from personal income, irrespective of the profit they earn from other economic activities or asset values. The government should implement a more innovative approach and use net wealth taxes – such as property transfer – and financial transaction taxes for trades of currency, stocks, and other financial instruments.
In 2020, the United Nations officially added an indicator to its Sustainable Development Goals to encourage policymakers to maximise fiscal policies to reduce inequality. Tulane University had even developed Commitment to Equity (CEQ) tools to monitor the impact of fiscal policies on inequality and poverty.
In other words, the choice of approaches is in our own hands.
We can choose to push more incentives toward the business sectors that have the potential to multiply the wealth of entrepreneurs, or we can strengthen our tax policy. We can opt to tolerate tax evasion, or we can decide to improve tax records and impose more significant penalties for those who neglect their tax obligations. Otherwise, we can also choose to increase the budget for social protection or distribute it to non-essential sectors.
In Indonesia, we need to improve at least three aspects.
First, the government must refocus tax policies, especially by optimising measures for income tax.
Currently, Indonesia’s highest proportion of tax revenue comes from corporate income tax, followed by VAT or goods tax and service tax. The government’s decision in October 2021 to increase taxable income by 35% for individual taxpayers who earn above Rp 5 billion per year should be appreciated.
However, this effort should accompany increasing taxes on economic activities with high valuations, such as transactions of property asset sales or asset ownership in the financial market.
Although the current indirect tax scheme does not attempt to distinguish between primary and supporting materials, basic needs are still burdened by VAT rates and disadvantageous for the less privileged. For instance, cooking oil, considered a basic need, is included in the list of commodities with a VAT rate of up to 11%.
Second, we need to increase the quantity and quality of government spending.
Indonesian government spending on social protection in 2022 is only around 1.59%, or the second-lowest in ASEAN, below Cambodia at 3.8%, Malaysia at 2.50%, Vietnam at 2.15%, Myanmar at 3.18% and Timor-Leste, which reached 4.62%. This condition certainly hits the quality of public services in Indonesia.
For example, the minimal support for infrastructure and quality government schools forces the community to spend more money on private schools. In the long term, this impacts the decline in people’s purchasing power while also affecting economic growth.
Thus, the government must increase financial allocations for vulnerable people while opening access to job opportunities. It can also reduce spending on the military sector to make more room for fiscal space. Despite the COVID-19 pandemic-related declines in economic output, the Ministry of Defense’s annual budget increased by 13.28% to Rp 134 trillion in 2021.
Third, the country should encourage efforts to reduce tax evasion and space for corruptors in the tax sector. To make this happen, the government may promote continuous public discussion while involving the community and civic organisations to have a constructive conversation.
Finally, the government is responsible for ensuring a fair tax system. However, we should not forget that entrepreneurs, including millionaires, play a significant role in creating an equitable economic system.
As British multimillionaire and financial activist Phil White has put it, “tax the richest and tax us now”. This statement is still rarely heard from the rich in Indonesia.
Reuters
Tue Jun 28 2022
Ironically, the support for businesses happens against the backdrop of increasing income inequality. - Filepic
Mesyuarat perundingan Enam Pihak Arab bincangkan perkembangan di Gaza
Mesyuarat perundingan Jawatankuasa Enam Pihak Arab itu membincangkan perkembangan serangan Israel ke atas Semenanjung Gaza.
Chegubard didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen KL esok - Peguam
Badrul Hisham Shaharin atau dikenali Chegubard akan didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen Kuala Lumpur esok atas pertuduhan memfitnah dan menghasut.
Pulau Pinang, kerajaan pusat bekerjasama tarik pelaburan semikonduktor
Kerajaan Pulau Pinang akan bekerjasama dengan Kerajaan Persekutuan untuk meneruskan usaha menarik pelaburan dalam sektor semikonduktor, termasuk segmen reka bentuk litar bersepadu (IC) di negeri itu.
Rakyat Malaysia di Jordan jadi duta produk PMKS negara
Menteri Pembangunan Usahawan dan Koperasi Datuk Ewon Benedick menyarankan rakyat Malaysia yang menetap di Jordan supaya memainkan peranan sebagai “duta” untuk mempromosikan produk perusahaan mikro kecil dan sederhana (PMKS) SERTA koperasi negara.
Mohamed Khaled tiba di Indonesia, dijadual bertemu Prabowo
Menteri Pertahanan Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin tiba di Jakarta hari ini untuk lawatan kerja rasmi sulung beliau ke Indonesia sejak memegang jawatan itu.
SPRM mohon maklumat dari Jerman
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) memohon maklumat terkini daripada pihak berkuasa Jerman mengenai dana bon 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) yang dipercayai digunakan untuk membeli kereta mewah di negara itu pada 26 Okt 2022.
SPRM siasat pemimpin kanan di utara tanah air
Seorang pemimpin kanan di utara tanah air disiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) kerana disyaki melantik beberapa syarikat yang mempunyai kepentingan dengannya membabitkan beberapa projek pembekalan melibatkan peruntukan kira-kira RM300,000.
Kembangkan kandungan tempatan melalui AI
Menurut Setiausaha Agung Organisasi Kerjasama Digital (DCO) Deemah Al Yahya, terdapat 2.7 peratus daripada penduduk dunia tidak berhubung malah tidak mempunyai sambungan asas internet. Beliau turut berkata infrastruktur pengkomputeran setiap negara perlu mempunyai kemampuan untuk mengembangkan kandungan tempatan khususnya yang melibatkan penggunaan AI.
AI tidak dapat ganti guru
Menteri Pendidikan Rwanda, Gaspard Twagirayezu berkata kepesatan teknologi AI dalam pendidikan tidak dapat menggantikan guru malah membantu guru dalam menyediakan bahan pengajaran yang bermanfaat kepada pelajar.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Ahad, 28 April 2024.
WEF anjur mesyuarat khas di Arab Saudi ketika suhu geopolitik Asia Barat memanas
WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28-29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
WEF24: Fintech global terus kukuh disokong permintaan tinggi
Industri teknologi kewangan (Fintech) global menunjukkan kekuatan dan daya tahan serta terus berkembang disebalik unjuran ekonomi tidak menentu.
WEF24: Malaysia sertai pakatan peralihan tenaga bersih negara membangun
Negara anggota akan turut berkongsi amalan terbaik untuk menarik kemasukan modal dalam teknologi baharu yang lebih mampan.
AMNC 2023: Saling percaya ialah teras kesejahteraan global - Presiden WEF
Perkongsian terbuka perlu terus digalakkan antara negara-negara untuk berdepan dengan pelbagai cabaran global yang tidak menunjukkan tanda mereda.
WEF2023: Perlu pendekatan menyeluruh tangani risiko - Tengku Zafrul
Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz berkata, kebergantungan terhadap kerajaan sahaja dalam menangani risiko adalah tidak memadai.
'Kerjasama Di Sebalik Perpecahan Dunia': Ini fakta penting WEF 2023
WEF23 menghimpunkan lebih 2,700 pemimpin dan pakar dari 130 negara, termasuk lebih 370 tokoh daripada kerajaan dan organisasi antarabangsa, lebih 1,500 pemimpin perniagaan dan lebih 90 inovator.
Pendidikan 4.0: Tiga kemahiran diperlukan untuk pekerjaan masa depan
Tiga kemahiran ini akan memainkan peranan bagi menaik taraf sistem pendidikan sedia ada demi perkembangan kerjaya masa depan.
Malaysia perlu lebih terlibat dalam pembuatan dasar peringkat rantau dan global - Shahril Hamdan
Kita tidak boleh lagi asyik berbicara hal-hal picisan yang tidak membawa kepada pembangunan negara.
Ketika ekonomi digital melonjak, jenayah siber turut meningkat
Secara puratanya terdapat 270 serangan siber bagi setiap organisasi sepanjang 2021, peningkatan sebanyak 31 peratus berbanding 2020.
Usaha korporat berkembang, tetapi lebih banyak diperlukan untuk penuhi cabaran karbon sifar bersih - Kajian
Pada 2019, hanya 10 peratus daripada pelepasan global dilindungi oleh ikrar kerajaan 29 negara untuk mencapai pelepasan sifar bersih.