If you want to understand why many Arab world leaders hate Al Jazeera, consider "Sharia and Life."
For years, the call-in show was one of the network's most popular, reaching tens of millions. Viewers would call in and pose their faith questions to Yusuf al-Qaradawi, an Egyptian cleric and a spiritual leader of the Muslim Brotherhood. People would ask all kinds of things: Is it okay to smoke during Ramadan? Does a female Palestinian woman have to wear a hijab while carrying out a suicide bombing?
Before Al Jazeera, a show like this would have been unusual in the Arab world, where media is tightly controlled. But the Qatari-owned network has a mandate to produce ambitious journalism on a wide range of subjects (some taboo). It offers, too, a broader range of opinions than most Arab media.
These qualities have made it the most popular network in the Middle East. It's also attracted a lot of enemies. Rulers in places like Saudi Arabia and Egypt resent the station's broad reach and its willingness to rile up opposition. They don't like its Islamist bent, and they're angry that their populations are exposed to reporting critical of their regimes (and supportive of the Qatari agenda).
For years, they've called on the station to evolve, or go away. Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Jordan have kicked Al Jazeera bureaus out of their countries. Saudi Arabia has also banned hotels from offering the channel. And now Qatar is embroiled in a diplomatic war with a group of Arab states, and shuttering Al Jazeera appears to be one key demand.
---
There are about 350 million Arab speakers across the Middle East. As far back as the 1950s and '60s, radio stations tried to reach this group. Sawt al-Arab radio, for example, was created by Egypt to spread Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser's Pan-Arabist ideas. (It was so effective that Nasser's political opponents in Saudi Arabia jammed the station. "Plus que le meme chose, plus que change.")
In the 1990s, the Saudi royal family began buying Arabic newspapers and sharing them across the region. They also developed a satellite station MBC, intended for a broad audience. That never quite caught on, but it did show would-be moguls the potential of pan-Arabic media.
It taught the region's leaders something else, too: that they might well lose their death grip on the information their populations were able to consume. As Shibley Telhami, who wrote a book on Arab media, explained, "this simultaneous sense of inspiration and threat is likely what inspired the emir of Qatar, Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani, to start Al Jazeera ... in 1996." Since then, the country has poured billions into the network.
Thani had come to power only a year before, and he faced fierce criticism from the Saudi-run newspapers. Al Jazeera, he hoped, would offer a different perspective, and maybe cut into the people consuming Saudi media.
To build an audience, the channel produced content that would appeal to people. As Telhami explained: "Viewers were exposed to programming that most Arabs hungered for, from opposing opinions to more information on issues they cared deeply about as Arabs and Muslims. This included live footage of bloodshed in Israeli confrontations with the Palestinians - footage that Arab national television broadcasts limited so as not to awaken their public's passion."
The station broke other important barriers too. It sent reporters to the Israeli Knesset and aired debates live. During the 2008 Gaza war, Al Jazeera had more reporters on the ground than anyone else, and it was the only station with live coverage. It also, Telhami writes, pushed for "presentation of multiple views, including presenting Israeli views dating back to the 1990s, when few other Arab stations dared do so, as well as airing Bin Laden tapes, Iranian views, and hosting or covering speeches and news conferences of American officials - including then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, American military commanders and spokesmen, and White House and State Department officials - during the Iraq war."
These qualities were major selling points. By 2001, it had become the most-watched Arab television station for news. By 2006, more than 75 percent of Arabs called the network their favorite or second-favorite news source.
The network's success, though, also made it a target of criticism, both from the outside and from within. After Sept. 11, 2001, Americans accused the channel of stoking anger and fear about U.S. foreign policy. In 2012, China took action against Al Jazeera English. Indeed, the channel has probably alienated every regional leader at one point or another.
Al Jazeera Arabic (which is run separately from Al Jazeera English) has also got a reputation for supporting the Muslim Brotherhood. Hugh Miles, the author of "The Al Jazeera Effect," compared the network to Fox News, telling the Telegraph that "Al Jazeera Arabic is very partisan and it supports Islamists. I think that's a defensible position because there are lots of Islamists and it's a popular view in many parts of the world. It's not accepted by other Arab countries, which regard it as seditious and threatening, but they offer another perspective."
"Al Jazeera is sensationalist, Islamic, and pan-Arabic, but it mirrors Doha's policy concerns in more ways than it might care to acknowledge," wrote Simon Henderson, director of the Washington Institute's Gulf and Energy Policy Program, just four years after the network's launch. "Many Arab governments would prefer Al Jazeera to simply disappear."
The latest diplomatic kerfuffle has some of the station's reporters worried that that's what's going to happen. While the station released a statement calling the demand for its closure "nothing but an attempt to silence the freedom of expression in the region," its staffers worry that Qatar might agree to, say, restructure things so that the network has less freedom. Some of its foreign reporters from places such as Egypt or Syria worry that they might be sent back to their home countries.
Still, the network's journalists say they're staying positive.
"There may be things going on at higher diplomatic and political levels," Al Jazeera English editor Giles Trendle told the Telegraph. "But from Al Jazeera's side, I would just say we are confident that we're here to stay and we're committed to carrying on with our jobs and carrying on with our journalism."
The Washington Post
Sat Jun 24 2017
Before Al Jazeera, a show like this would have been unusual in the Arab world, where media is tightly controlled.
Kotak hitam helikopter mendarat cemas di Pulau Angsa dihantar ke Itali
Kotak hitam helikopter AW139 milik Maritim Malaysia yang melakukan pendaratan cemas di sekitar perairan Pulau Angsa, Kuala Selangor telah dihantar ke Itali.
Polis bongkar makmal haram milik suami isteri, rampas dadah bernilai RM1.4 juta
Polis membongkar sebuah makmal haram dan stor penyimpanan dadah milik sepasang suami isteri dalam tiga serbuan berasingan di sekitar Lembah Klang.
Raih RM35.3 juta, Sheriff kini filem No. 1 dengan kutipan tertinggi tahun ini
Kejayaan ini menyaksikan Sheriff mengetepikan filem besar antarabangsa dan terus mendominasi carta kutipan tahun ini.
MOM jangka 10 lagi atlet akan raih tiket ke Olimpik Paris
Presiden Majlis Olimpik Malaysia (MOM) Tan Sri Mohamad Norza Zakaria mengesahkan bahawa sebanyak 18 atlet kebangsaan daripada tujuh jenis sukan layak ke Olimpik Paris 2024 setakat hari ini.
Kelas terapung atasi masalah sekolah padat - Fadhlina
Pelaksanaan kelas terapung di sekolah-sekolah yang mempunyai kepadatan tinggi dapat membantu mengatasi isu kesesakan pelajar.
Tak tinggal sebumbung, Nora Danish akui rumah tangga bergolak
Nora mengakui rumah tangga yang dibina tujuh tahun lalu goyah, namun mereka berdua sedang berusaha untuk menangani kemelut tersebut.
Penolong pegawai perubatan didenda RM3,000 terima rasuah urus jenazah
Seorang penolong pegawai perubatan di Hospital Sultan Haji Ahmad Shah Temerloh didenda RM3,000 kerana menerima rasuah berkaitan kerja pengurusan jenazah.
KBS laksana kajian impak penganjuran Sukan SEA 2027
Mesyuarat mengenai perkara itu masih berjalan dengan penglibatan pelbagai pihak bagi mengenal pasti kelebihan dan kekurangan.
19 individu ditahan dipercayai terbabit sindiket pelaburan palsu
Mereka terdiri daripada lapan lelaki dan tujuh wanita tempatan serta empat lelaki warga asing berusia antara 16 hingga 38 tahun.
[TERKINI] Selamatkan Gaza: Dialog dua Perdana Menteri di Mesyuarat Khas WEF Arab Saudi
Tiga PM iaitu PM Palestin, Jordan dan Mesir serta wakil PBB di Gaza duduk sepentas berdialog secara langsung mencari formula menyelamatkan Gaza yang menjadi pusat graviti kepada kestabilan rantau Asia Barat.
Al Jazeera kutuk pembunuhan ahli keluarga wartawan Wael Dahdouh
Al Jazeera seru masyarakat antarabangsa turut serta dalam usaha mengakhiri serangan ke atas orang awam, sekali gus melindungi nyawa golongan yang tidak berdosa.
Serangan meningkat di Gaza, kakitangan Al Jazeera cari tempat berlindung
Siaran Al Jazeera dari Gaza pada pukul 3 pagi terpaksa dihentikan disebabkan bimbang dengan tahap keselamatan.
Jual vape: 'Malaysia seolah-olah sudah memasuki era 'Wild Wild West' - Khairy
Bekas Menteri Kesihatan, Khairy Jamaluddin menyuarakan kebimbangan beliau berhubung penjualan berleluasa vape tanpa kawalan di Malaysia, sehingga menarik minat media antarabangsa.
Al Jazeera ulangi ikrar bela kematian wartawan Shireen Abu Akleh
Al Jazeera akan mencari keadilan kepada Shireen dengan mendesak melalui pelbagai cara untuk memastikan pembunuhnya diheret ke pengadilan.
Wartawan Al Jazeera maut ditembak tentera Israel
wartawan Al Jazeera, Shireen Abu Akleh merupakan seorang wartawan yang sangat dihormati.
Pejabat biro AP dan Al Jazeera di Gaza musnah dalam serangan udara Israel
Sebelum ini pemilik bangunan telah diberi amaran bahawa serangan peluru berpandu itu akan muncul menyerang premis berkenaan.
Malaysia jatuh 18 anak tangga dalam Indeks Kebebasan Media 2021 - RSF
Malaysia jatuh 18 tangga dari tempat ke-101 pada 2020 ke tempat ke-119 tahun ini.
Mesir bebaskan wartawan Al Jazeera selepas empat tahun dalam tahanan
Mahmoud Hussein ditahan pada Disember 2016 atas tuduhan menyebarkan berita palsu, menyertai kumpulan haram dan menerima dana asing.
Jho Low percaya tidak lakukan kesalahan, dakwa hanya pinjam wang 1MDB
Ahli perniagaan dalam buruan, Low Taek Jho atau Jho Low yang menjadi 'mastermind' dalam skandal 1MDB mendedahkan dia tidak melakukan kesalahan dan hanya meminjam wang daripada 1MDB.
Dakwa hakim saudara Tun M: Polis sudah kenal pasti pemilik akaun Twitter
Individu itu akan dipanggil minggu depan bagi memberi keterangan berhubung dakwaan tersebut.