STATEMENT BY GOBIND SINGH DEO:
The Attorney-General's response to the US DOJ suit yesterday raises serious concerns.
Firstly, and with respect, he should decide where he stands. Is he the defence lawyer for the Prime Minister or is the Public Prosecutor of Malaysia?
To my mind, he should not be leaping to the Prime Minister’s defence. He should maintain his independence and be open to the fact that serious allegations have been made in the suit which may lead to him having to reopen the case here at some stage.
Making broad comments and issuing veiled warnings to the effect that he has “strong concerns at insinuations and allegations” made against the Prime Minister at this stage seriously undermines public confidence in his office as Public Prosecutor.
The Prime Minister is capable of looking after himself. The Public Prosecutor should remain impartial and independent.
Apandi should also not hide behind legal semantics in attempting to fend off concerns expressed over the liability of “Malaysian Official 1” in the suit.
He says the there has been no evidence which shows that money has been misappropriated from 1MDB and there have been no criminal charges preferred against any individuals for offences of misappropriation of funds from 1MDB.
Again, with respect, that isn't the point.
It is not the label but the substance which counts. Whether or not there has been conduct which warrants criminal prosecution depends on the facts of each case.
For example, in a civil suit for damages arising from assault, it is true that the suit filed would be civil in nature but the allegation of assault therein may be sufficient to support a criminal prosecution as well. Likewise, in a case in which a suit is filed to recover monies allegedly wrongly used, wrongly channelled or otherwise. The same facts could warrant a criminal investigation and criminal charge as well.
So, to say that particular individuals have not been named or that no criminal charges have been preferred against any individual does not justify a closure to the subject of discussion altogether.
In this case, Apandi should start by telling us who Malaysian Official 1 is.
Apandi must further respond to the questions posed by DAP MP for Petaling Jaya Utara Tony Pua yesterday when he asked:
“page 75, paragraph 263 of the document states that Attorney-General Mohamed Apandi Ali had cleared Malaysian Official 1 in the inquiry on US$681 million.”
He therefore called on Apandi to explain the latter's claim that the money channelled into those accounts was from an Arab donor.
Tony said the documents from DOJ suggest that the US$681 million originated from a US$3 billion bond 1MDB raised.
This strikes at the heart of the propriety of the decision made by Apandi. This must now, in light of the suit, be addressed.
In addition to this, Apandi must now tell us if it is true that the MACC had asked him to assist in the form of an application for mutual assistance in investigations into the case.
If so, did he reject it as alleged and if he did, does that mean that Malaysia is now in no position to dispute the facts in the DOJ suit for the simple reason that no full inquiry was conducted into the matter for failure on his part to obtain mutual assistance as alleged?
These are serious matters of public interest which warrant a public response. I call upon the Attorney General not to shy away from these questions and to respond forthwith.
*Gobind Singh Deo is DAP's Chairman of National Legal Bureau and Member of Parliament, Puchong.
** The opinions and views expressed in this article are those of the author's and do not reflect the view of Astro AWANI.
Astro Awani
Fri Jul 22 2016
Gobind Singh Deo says, Tan Sri Mohamed Apandi Ali should maintain his independence and be open to the fact that serious allegations have been made in the suit. - FILEpic
Misi teroka peluang ekonomi, tarik pelaburan baharu di WEF - PM
Delegasi Malaysia akan berkongsi dasar dan hala tuju negara di samping mempertegas pendirian negara dalam isu geopolitik serantau di hadapan pemimpin dunia.
JBPM Terengganu berdepan kesukaran padam kebakaran
JBPM Terengganu menghadapi kesukaran memadamkan kebakaran di Kampung Sungai Ikan Kuala Nerus yang melibatkan lebih 75% tapak pelupusan sampah
Polis jangka laporan baharu selepas berkas guru tahfiz
Polis Kelantan menjangkakan lebih banyak laporan polis berkenaan pencabulan di sebuah pusat tahfiz di Machang selepas penahanan seorang guru.
Polis Jerman rampas 4 kereta Bugatti Veyron edisi terhad yang dikaitkan dengan 1MDB
Kenderaan berkenaan dikatakan sebahagian daripada siri "Legenda" khas Bugatti Veyron, dengan hanya 18 daripada supercar tersebut dibina dalam enam spesifikasi.
Gempa kuat 6.5 skala Richter gegar Garut, impak dirasai hingga Jakarta
Badan Meteorologi, Klimatologi dan Geofisika (BMKG) Indonesia merekodkan gempa berkekuatan 6.5 skala Richter pada malam Sabtu.
EPL: Jika saya bercakap akan berlaku pergaduhan - Salah
Salah sangat tegang dengan Klopp ketika dia bersedia untuk masuk sebagai pemain gantian pada minit ke-79.
Rumah Najib boleh jadi penjara - Peguam
Rumah bekas Perdana Menteri itu boleh dijadikan sebagai penjara dan tempat tahanan untuk beliau seperti yang termaktub dalam undang-undang.
Kopi, kanvas seni Tyler Wong
Kopi ialah kanvas untuk Tyler Wong mempamerkan kemahiran dalam mencipta seni latte yang rumit namun indah.
Mayat tanpa identiti ditemukan terapung di Sungai Linggi
Mayat dipercayai seorang lelaki ditemukan terapung di kawasan Sungai Linggi berhampiran Pusat Dakwah Islamiah Paroi, di sini petang Sabtu.
AWANI Ringkas: Lawatan sempena mesyuarat khas WEF
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Kes 1MDB: Najib percaya Blackstone dikawal Arab Saudi, Raja Abdullah - Saksi
Saksi memberitahu Najib percaya bahawa syarikat Blackstone Asia Real Estate Partners dikawal oleh kerajaan Arab Saudi dan Raja Arab Saudi.
1MDB: Prosiding Najib julung kali dibuat pada Sabtu
Perbicaraan pertama dibuat pada hujung minggu ini berlangsung tepat jam 8.30 pagi, selepas bekas Perdana Menteri itu dibawa pihak berkuasa dengan menaiki kenderaan dari Jabatan Penjara.
'Kementerian Kewangan tiada rekod surat kelulusan Najib bagi 1MDB ambil alih Tanjong Energy, Genting Sanyen' - Saksi
Dalam siasatan SPRM, Kementerian Kewangan mengesahkan tidak mempunyai rekod ke atas kedua-dua surat tersebut.
Najib diberi peluang jelaskan mengenai dokumen 1MDB ketika disoal siasat - Pegawai SPRM
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Najib diberi peluang untuk menjelaskan secara terperinci mengenai dokumen berkaitan 1MDB, ketika disoal siasat.
Najib tak pernah arah pengurusan 1MDB pindah AS$1.03 bilion kepada syarikat Jho Low - Saksi
Mahkamah Tinggi diberitahu bahawa Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak tidak pernah mengarahkan mana-mana individu daripada pengurusan 1MDB untuk memindahkan AS$1.03 bilion kepada syarikat Jho low.
Tidak penting untuk tanya jika Najib arah AS$700 juta dipindah kepada syarikat Jho Low - Saksi
Saksi itu berkata demikian ketika disoal oleh peguam Wan Azwan Aiman Wan Fakhruddin berhubung transaksi yang dilakukan pada September 2009.
1MDB: Mahkamah akan tentukan sama ada pendakwaan berjaya buktikan kes - Hakim
Muhammad Shafee berhujah bahawa pertuduhan terhadap anak guamnya adalah salah serta bertindih.
1MDB: SPRM ke Riyadh untuk sahkan surat derma RM2.6 bilion - Saksi
Penguasa Kanan SPRM Nur Aida Arifin berkata pihaknya telah pergi ke Istana Riyadh pada 2015 bagi mengadakan pertemuan dengan dua putera Arab Saudi.
1MDB: Najib tak dedah mengenai pertemuan dengan Raja Arab Saudi ketika siasatan - Saksi
Najib tidak memaklumkan kepada SPRM mengenai pertemuan delegasi Malaysia bersama Raja Arab Saudi, Almarhum Raja Abdullah Abdul Aziz Al-Saud.
1MDB: Muhammad Shafee ditegur hakim kerana bersikap 'keterlaluan'
Ketua peguam bela yang mewakili Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak ditegur apabila dilihat menyerang kredibiliti pengawai penyiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) ketika perbicaraan.