The defence in Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's appeal today questioned whether there was penetration in the alleged sodomy case as Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan's testimony was inconsistent over the existence of
a lubricant in the act.
Lawyer Datuk Seri Gopal Sri Ram, a former Federal Court judge, argued that according to the evidence from the complainant Mohd Saiful at the High Court,the act was vigorous and fast and he suffered pain in his anus and stomach.
Submitting before a five-member panel of the Federal Court chaired by Chief Justice Tun Arifin Zakaria, Sri Ram said if that was correct, then a lubricant called KY Jelly could not have been used because it was to facilitate penetration and avoid pain.
He pointed out that the medical evidence had confirmed that no trauma or injury was found in Mohd Saiful's anus.
Sri Ram further said the lubricant was not mentioned in the list of exhibits recovered by the prosecution from Mohd Saiful, who was the prosecution's first witness in the sodomy trial.
"The absence of lubricant from the list casts serious doubt on the credibility of Mohd Saiful, and lack of credibility in the prosecution's case and the entire investigation," he said, adding that Mohd Saiful had also not mentioned in his police report on the usage of KY Jelly.
At this juncture, Justice Arifin asked Sri Ram why he said lack of credibility, to which he replied if the gel was used Mohd Saiful would not have suffered pain.
Sri Ram submitted that the learned trial judge did not address his mind to this part of the case at all despite strenuous cross-examination on the point (KY Jelly) by lawyer Karpal Singh.
Sri Ram said Mohd Saiful in his testimony said that the semen stayed in his anus for several days but in his evidence when cross-examined by Karpal, said he did not take a bath after the incident and only rinsed his body and he had taken a bath in the morning prior to the incident.
"It shows inconsistency in Mohd Saiful's testimony," he said.
Sri Ram said the KY gel was an important exhibit but had only appeared during the examination-in-chief by the prosecution on Mohd Saiful and futhermore, Mohd Saiful had told the court he himself bought the gel before proceeding to the condominium.
Bernama
Tue Oct 28 2014
Sri Ram pointed out that the medical evidence had confirmed that no trauma or injury was found in Mohd Saiful's anus. - File Photo
SWCorp yakin sasaran kadar kitar semula kebangsaan tahun ini tercapai
Keyakinan itu berdasarkan peratusan yang dicapai pada tahun sebelum ini melebihi sasaran ditetapkan.
Kerajaan perlu jana lebih hasil untuk tampung perbelanjaan kenaikan gaji, faedah - RHB Research
Peningkatan perbelanjaan emolumen daripada kenaikan gaji penjawat awam boleh dibiayai melalui kutipan hasil yang lebih tinggi.
Malaysia, Uzbekistan akan ubah jawatankuasa bersama dalam perdagangan kepada suruhanjaya bersama
Malaysia dan Uzbekistan telah bersetuju untuk mengaktifkan Jawatankuasa Bersama Perdagangan Antara Kerajaan dan mengubah jawatankuasa itu menjadi Suruhanjaya Bersama Antara Kerajaan.
13 negara gesa sekatan terhadap Israel daripada serang Rafah
Antara negara yang menandatangani surat berkenaan ialah Australia, yang mana menteri-menteri luar negara terbabit turut meminta gencatan senjata yang mampan.
Sekolah di bandar Bitung ditutup
Sekolah-sekolah ditutup di Bandar Bitung selepas abu dan hujan dari gunung berapi Ruang mencurah di Sulawesi Utara Indonesia.
Brazil dipilih sebagai tuan rumah Piala Dunia Wanita FIFA 2027
Brazil akan menjadi tuan rumah Piala Dunia Wanita Persekutuan Bola Sepak Antarabangsa (FIFA) 2027 selepas undian di Kongres FIFA ke-74 pada Jumaat.
40 senator Thailand mohon pemecatan Srettha
Ketika rombakan Kabinet bulan lalu, senator itu membantah pelantikan bekas peguam, Pichit Cuenban, sebagai Menteri di pejabat Srettha.
Lelaki bakar rumah ibadat ditembak mati
Polis menembak mati seorang lelaki bersenjata yang membakar rumah ibadat di Rouen Perancis.
Bayaran dam dan korban melalui THiJARI diteruskan
Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH) meneruskan perkhidmatan bayaran dam dan korban melalui aplikasi THiJARI untuk musim haji tahun ini seperti tahun-tahun sebelumnya, bagi memudahkan bakal jemaah haji negara untuk melunaskan tanggungjawab masing-masing.
Singapura kutuk, nasihat warganya di Malaysia berhati-hati
Singapura mengutuk sekeras-kerasnya serangan ke atas Balai Polis Ulu Tiram di Johor pada Jumaat, yang mengakibatkan kematian dua anggota polis dan mencederakan seorang lagi.
Langkah Dubai: 'Saya tahu, tapi tak boleh 'habaq' - Sanusi
Cakap-cakap politik berkait spekulasi 'Langkah Dubai' hari ini masih lagi kedengaran biar pun tiada sebarang bukti signifikan.
Rombakan Kabinet: Tidak adil buat penilaian dalam tempoh setahun - PM
Menteri atau timbalan menteri harus diberi peluang memperbaiki prestasi mereka termasuk beliau sendiri, kata Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Pentas PBB: Ucapan PM berani, tegas, berpijak pada realiti semasa - Reezal Merican
Pendirian yang ditunjukkan PM adalah jalan yang paling wajar dengan membuktikan tiada hipokrasi.
Ucapan sulung PM sentuh segala isu mustahak dunia - Syed Hamid
Isu-isu sensitif tetapi perlu disentuh seperti di Afghanistan, mencerminkan bahawa pendirian Malaysia adalah amat jelas sekali.
PM selesai jalani pembedahan kecil gigi
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim dalam perkongsian di laman Facebook memaklumkan beliau kini berada dalam pemantauan pihak hospital sehingga esok.
Malaysia bakal tarik lebih banyak syarikat automotif China
Sektor automotif juga perlu memastikan ekosistemnya memenuhi matlamat alam sekitar, sosial dan tadbir urus korporat (ESG) PBB.
PM mahu kesatuan rakyat ditingkatkan sempena Aidilfitri
Beliau turut mengucapkan salam Aidilfitri buat seluruh rakyat Malaysia.
LHDN layak siasat individu, syarikat elak bayar cukai - PM
Perdana Menteri menegaskan, selagi beliau diberikan amanah memimpin negara, beliau akan pastikan setiap individu patuh kepada undang-undang.
Malaysia-UAE sepakat tingkatkan kerjasama pelbagai bidang - PM Anwar
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim berharap akan dapat mengadakan lawatan ke Emiriah Arab Bersatu (UAE) dalam masa terdekat.
PM bertemu Erdogan, zahir solidariti Malaysia kepada Turkiye
Beliau dalam masa turut menyeru agar semua mendoakan peristiwa duka itu segera berlalu dan Turkiye kembali pulih.