KUALA LUMPUR: The choice between sales and service tax (SST) and the goods and services tax (GST) hinges on Malaysia's economic goals, administrative capabilities, and the need to achieve an optimal balance between revenue generation and the promotion of fairness and equity among the rakyat, said the Finance Ministry (MoF).
It said the SST, characterised by its narrower scope that concentrates on specific goods and services, serves as a subtle strategy in consumption tax.
"The GST model broadens the tax base, enhances compliance and transparency, improves efficiency and business-friendliness, and mobilises efficient revenue collection," the MoF said in its 2024 Fiscal Outlook and Federal Government Revenue Estimates report released today.
The MoF noted that the GST can potentially generate more revenue because of its broad base feature and is more transparent to consumers as it is explicitly shown in the final price.
"Additionally, the GST has the capacity to reduce the size of the shadow economy, hence benefiting the economy," the report said comparing the two tax systems.
In contrast, the SST might generate less revenue due to its narrow tax base. It is also less transparent to consumers as the tax may be embedded in the price of goods and services.
According to the ministry, the GST has no cascading effect as the tax levied on input is recoverable and not embedded in the cost, while there is "a cascading effect" in the SST because the tax element is embedded into the cost at each successive stage in the supply chain.
"At the same time, the overlapping of the two separate tax systems causes a cascading effect where an item may be taxed twice," it said.
With the GST, all exports are zero-rated, which enables hidden consumption tax to be identified because there is a rebate for it.
In the case of the SST, although exports are not taxed, the embedding of the tax element at each successive stage may increase the cost of exports, the report said.
On consumer impact, the MoF said the cost to business owners can be reduced because they can claim input credits from the government under the GST. Hence, the final price may be lower because there is no "cascading effect".
Under the SST structure, the sales tax is only charged at the manufacturers' level, which is indirectly compounded along the distribution chain and added to the tax element and the cost of products sold, the report said.
On tax evasion and compliance, the MoF said GST's self-policing mechanism can encourage better compliance and reduce tax evasion, but the SST is only imposed on certain goods and services. Therefore, the classification of the taxable status of an item or service may contribute to compliance issues, leading to tax evasion.
On the red tape for tax-free materials, the ministry said because the GST is a self-policing mechanism, taxable persons may offset input tax credit incurred against output tax liability, while with SST, registered manufacturers are required to apply for exemption certificates to acquire tax free materials.
Despite the differences in structures, both the SST and GST offer an important fiscal tool to fund government programmes and projects.
Malaysia has imposed the single-stage SST system since 1972. It was replaced by the GST at a rate of six per cent in April 2015 and abolished in May 2018. The SST returned on Sept 1, 2018.
--BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Oct 13 2023
Despite the differences in structures, both the SST and GST offer an important fiscal tool to fund government programmes and projects. - Astro AWANI/Filepic
PH kerja keras pertahan DUN KKB, tidak mahu berasa selesa
Walaupun berjaya menguasai kerusi Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB) selama tiga penggal sejak 2013, namun ia bukanlah tiket untuk Pakatan Harapan (PH) berasa selesa.
MDKpr nafi curi haiwan ternakan dalam kandang
Ahmad Suqairy berkata haiwan itu ditangkap dalam operasi oleh Bahagian Penguatkuasaan MDKpr pada 23 Apr lalu di kawasan Kolej TAR.
488 acara dipertandingkan di SUKMA Sarawak 2024 - MSN
Jawatankuasa Tertinggi Sukan Malaysia (SUKMA) secara rasmi bersetuju menawarkan sejumlah 488 acara dipertandingkan pada temasya SUKMA Sarawak 2024.
Petronas Dagangan catat jualan lebih 16 bilion liter bahan api pada 2023
PDB merekodkan peningkatan perolehan sebanyak dua peratus didorong jumlah jualan lebih tinggi dan keuntungan selepas cukai yang meningkat.
Aset rizab rasmi Malaysia berjumlah AS$113.76 bilion pada akhir Mac - BNM
Aset rizab rasmi Malaysia berjumlah AS$113.76 bilion pada akhir Mac 2024 manakala aset mata wang asing lain adalah US$1.61 bilion, kata Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM).
Kemunculan Momota di gelanggang pastinya dirindui - Pemain badminton dunia
Momota bakal bersara daripada arena sukan badminton antarabangsa selepas Piala Thomas 2024 yang sedang berlangsung di Chengdu.
Akta Sewaan Kediaman perlu digubal segera bagi pelihara hak pemilik, penyewa
Pertubuhan Sewaan Kediaman Kebangsaan hari ini meminta kerajaan menggubal Akta Sewaan Kediaman dengan segera bagi memastikan hak pemilik kediaman dan penyewa sentiasa terpelihara di negara ini.
Perkhidmatan komuter percuma sempena Program MADANI Rakyat Zon Utara
Langkah itu bagi memudahkan pengunjung di utara tanah air untuk datang memeriahkan program yang berlangsung tiga hari bermula Jumaat itu.
Nur Shazrin masih plilhan utama ke Paris - MSA
MSA tidak mahu menekan 'butang panik' selepas atletnya Nur Shazrin berdepan kemungkinan terlepas aksi di Sukan Olimpik Paris 2024 berikutan kecederaan berulang pada tangan kanannya.
PRK KKB: Jangan mengundi ikut emosi - Azalina
Sebaliknya, beliau berkata, pengundi perlu melihat kepada rekod perkhidmatan penyandangnya yang telah melaksanakan tugasnya dengan baik.
Harga petrol, diesel kekal bagi tempoh 11 hingga 17 April
Harga runcit bagi petrol RON97 dan RON95 serta diesel masing-masing kekal pada RM3.47, RM2.05 dan RM2.15 seliter bagi tempoh 11 hingga 17 April ini.
MOF komited laksana dasar fiskal progresif kurangkan kemiskinan, ketaksamaan
Sumbangan dasar fiskal terhadap inisiatif mengurangkan kemiskinan dan merapatkan jurang pendapatan adalah minimum dari segi KDNK.
PM akui wujud keresahan kenaikan harga barang, MOF sedia tampung kesan kenaikan
MOF sedia menampung dan memberi bantuan tambahan bagi mengimbangkan kesan kenaikan harga barangan kepada rakyat.
Harga petrol, diesel kekal dari 31 Ogos hingga 6 September
RON97 akan kekal pada RM3.37 seliter, RON95 (RM2.05 seliter) dan diesel (RM2.15 seliter)
Firma AS minat teroka kemasukan operasi perniagaan baharu ke Malaysia
Steven Sim berkata AMCHAM menekankan kepentingan kesinambungan kawal selia untuk membantu memudahkan menjalankan perniagaan.
Kerajaan laksana semula Program Pengakuan Sukarela mulai 6 Jun - MOF
Beri peluang kepada orang ramai secara sukarela bayar cukai yang bertanggungan tanpa penalti atau pada kadar sifar peratus.
MOF serah kepada Bank Negara cari remedi kukuhkan ringgit
Timbalan Menteri Kewangan I, Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan berkata, beliau yakin Bank Negara mempunyai penyelesaian sekiranya AS belum membuat keputusan terhadap permintaan tersebut.
Muhyiddin dakwa tetap akan diheret ke mahkamah atas arahan pihak tertinggi pentadbiran negara
Muhyiddin mendakwa SPRM tidak menemui sebarang bukti terhadap segala pertuduhan yang dikaitkan dengan beliau
Cukuplah mercu tanda sedia ada, saya tak berhajat buat satu lagi - Anwar
Tumpuan sebaliknya diberikan kepada aspek kemampanan pembangunan sesebuah bandar terutama di ibu kota Kuala Lumpur.
Kebakaran di Kementerian Kewangan: Tiada kecederaan, kerugian - MoF
Kementerian Kewangan mengesahkan berlaku kebakaran melibatkan bilik sampah di kompleks kementerian itu di sini pada Selasa.