PUTRAJAYA: The family of a lorry driver P. Chandran will receive a sum of RM357,500 in damages over his death in police custody in 2012 after his medical needs were not attended to.
This is despite the Federal Court seven-member bench majority 6-1 in allowing the appeal by the police and government on a point of law that the family of the deceased was not entitled to receive exemplary damages for his death while in police custody.
Federal Court judge Datuk Rhodzariah Bujang who delivered the court's majority decision, said there was nothing in the Federal Constitution that provides, in any direct or vague way, the right of a deceased's estate to exemplary damages.
Although the Federal Court did not uphold the High Court's decision to award RM200,000 in exemplary damages to Chandran's family, the court instead retains the RM200,000 as aggravated damages.
“Since the respondents (the deceased's family) have pleaded for aggravated damages in their statement of claim but was not granted, we have decided to set aside the quantum for exemplary damages ordered by the High Court judge and substitute the same with that under aggravated damages,” she said.
The High Court, in allowing the lawsuit filed by Chandran's family in 2016, had ordered the police and the government to pay a total sum of RM357,500 in damages which included RM200,000 in exemplary damages.
The police and the government subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal only on the award of the sum of RM200,000 in exemplary damages which they contended that payment of exemplary damages could not be awarded to family members of the deceased.
They, however, lost their appeal in the Court of Appeal and subsequently obtained leave from the Federal Court to appeal against the appellate court's dismissal of their appeal.
The majority decision came from Court of Appeal President Tan Sri Rohana Yusuf, Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak Datuk Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim, Federal Court judges Datuk Abdul Rahman Sebli, Datuk Zabariah Mohd Yusof and Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Justice Rhodzariah.
Federal Court judge Datuk Nallini Pathmanathan dissented, saying that Chandran was deprived of his fundamental right to life while being held in custody.
She said although the Civil Law Act 196 barred further relief in the form of punitive damages against the government, the deceased's estate was entitled to receive such punitive damages for breach of his right to life under Article 5 (1) of the Federal Constitution.
“The damages of RM200,000 awarded by the High Court were clearly punitive in nature to indicate the court's outrage at the conduct of the authorities, resulting in his (Chandran's) unnecessary death," said Justice Nallini.
She said the courts should be vigilant to protect the rights of those in custody to ensure that they were not subjected to custodial death but should be equally vigilant to ensure that falsely motivated and frivolous claims were rejected.
On January 16, 2015, coroner Datuk Ahmad Bache who heard the inquest into Chandran's death held that police were responsible for the death through their omission to provide Chandran with timely medical assistance.
In September 2015, Selvi and Rita filed a civil lawsuit against the seven appellants — five police officers, Inspector-General of police and the Malaysian Government — claiming that Chandran’s death was caused by their negligence and that their conduct amounted to public misfeasance and breach of the deceased’s constitutional rights.
On January 9, 2016, the High Court in Kuala Lumpur ruled that the death of the 47-year old Chandran was due to police negligence and awarded a total sum of RM357,500 in damages.
The sum awarded comprised RM200,000 in exemplary damages, loss of dependency RM144,000, RM10,000 for bereavement and RM3,500 in special damages.
Chandran was detained by police on suspicion of being involved in an abduction case of a newborn baby.
Lawyer M.Visvanathan represented Chandran's family while senior federal counsel Andi Razalijaya appeared for the police and government.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Mar 22 2021
The family of a lorry driver P. Chandran will receive a sum of RM357,500 in damages over his death in police custody in 2012 after his medical needs were not attended to.
Kanak-kanak Malaysia tidak cukup belajar di sekolah - Laporan Bank Dunia
Hanya 58 peratus pelajar di Malaysia didapati mahir membaca menjelang akhir Darjah 5.
Protes di universiti AS tidak tunjuk tanda perlahan
Dalam dua minggu lalu, protes pro-Palestin telah merebak ke kampus kolej utama di seluruh AS.
37 juta tan serpihan runtuhan di Gaza - UNMAS
Terdapat juga sejumlah besar senjata api yang tidak meletup tertimbus di dalam runtuhan yang menimbulkan risiko kepada kerja pembersihan.
Legenda EPL puji padang SNBJ
Pemain Manchester Reds dan Liverpool Reds memuji keadaan rumput yang cantik dan bersedia untuk kembali beraksi pada masa akan datang.
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Dunia saling tidak percaya akibat kebergantungan dipersenjatakan - Naib Presiden Suruhanjaya Eropah
Fenomena hilang kepercayaan yang melanda komuniti antarabangsa ketika ini adalah akibat kebergantungan yang dipersenjatakan oleh beberapa pihak.
Che'gu Bard tiba di mahkamah bagi hadapi pertuduhan kes fitnah, hasut
Badrul Hisham, yang memakai baju Melayu berwarna hijau, dibawa oleh pihak polis ke mahkamah dalam keadaan bergari.
WCK sambung misi bantuan di Gaza
Operasi itu disambung sebulan selepas tujuh pekerja badan amal itu terbunuh dalam serangan udara Israel.
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: Dunia perlukan persaingan sihat dalam transisi ke Orde Baharu - Menteri Luar Arab Saudi
Dunia memerlukan persaingan sihat dalam transisi daripada Orde Dunia Lama kepada Orde Baharu.
Niaga AWANI: Jiwa SME: Permintaan daun moringa meningkat, jadi tumpuan luar negara
Berdasarkan laporan Vodus Market Research, sebuah firma penyelidikan dan analisis data pasaran dalam talian, kira-kira 71 peratus penduduk di negara ini mengambil suplemen pada 2021.
Nilai pasaran suplemen negara juga menunjukkan peningkatan ketara dalam tempoh 2014 hingga 2019, iaitu daripada RM2.07 bilion kepada RM3.1 bilion. Angka itu dijangka terus meningkat pada masa akan datang.
Nilai pasaran suplemen negara juga menunjukkan peningkatan ketara dalam tempoh 2014 hingga 2019, iaitu daripada RM2.07 bilion kepada RM3.1 bilion. Angka itu dijangka terus meningkat pada masa akan datang.
Niaga AWANI: FBM KLCI mencapai paras tertinggi walaupun ditengah cabaran Ringgit
Indeks FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI meningkat sebanyak 8.28% walaupun nilai matawang menurun sebanyak 3.79% berbanding dollar Amerika Syarikat (AS). Adakah trend ini akan berterusan sehingga bulan Mei akan datang? Kupasan lanjut bersama Ketua Penyelidikan dan Penasihat Kekayaan, Pengurus Portfolio, UOB Kay Hian Wealth Advisors, Mohd Sedek Jantan.