PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court has dismissed the appeal by National Feedlot Corporation Sdn Bhd (NFCorp) and its executive chairman, Datuk Seri Dr Mohamad Salleh Ismail over their defamation suit against Permatang Pauh Member of Parliament (MP), Nurul Izzah Anwar and PKR.
A three-member bench comprising Federal Court judges Datuk Seri Mohd Zawawi Salleh, Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Datuk Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal upheld the decisions of the High Court and Court of Appeal in dismissing NFCorp and Mohamad Salleh's defamation suit.
Justice Harmindar Singh, who delivered the court's decision, said Nurul Izzah and Saifuddin Nasution Ismail, who was sued in his capacity as PKR secretary-general, had made out the defence of justification and they could not be liable for damages for defamation.
He also said that the High Court held that Nurul Izzah’s statement read in its entirety was not defamatory.
The court ordered NFCorp and Mohamad Salleh to pay RM50,000 in costs.
NFCorp and Mohamad Salleh filed the suit on Dec 4, 2013 against Nurul Izzah, who was then Lembah Pantai MP, and Saifuddin in relation to their statements over allegations concerning the purchase of eight units of property at KL Eco City.
They claimed that Nurul Izzah had made a slanderous statement on Malaysiakini TV on March 7, 2012.
The High Court had on March 4, 2016, dismissed NFCorp and Mohamad Salleh's lawsuit and they also lost their appeal in the Court of Appeal which was also dismissed on July 10, 2017.
In the court's unanimous decision, Justice Harmindar Singh said the Court of Appeal had agreed with the findings of the High Court that there was substantial truth in the statement at the press conference which was on the conflict of interest surrounding Mohamad Salleh's wife, Tan Sri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil when she was the MP for Lembah Pantai.
Justice Harmindar said the focus of Nurul Izzah's press statement was on the perceived injustice done to those squatters by having to make way with scant compensation.
He said the focus was also on whether there was any conflict of interest by Mohamed Salleh's wife when eight units of condominium were purchased by her own family including Mohamad Salleh.
Justice Harmindar said it was the court's view that the real question for determination was related to the impression created in the mind of the ordinary and reasonable viewer after viewing the whole press statement.
"In our assessment, such a person will not pay any attention to the alleged defamatory matter complained about, which was in effect one sentence in a very long press statement and instead be focused only on the major part of the press statement concerning the wife of the first plaintiff (Mohamad Salleh)," he said.
The judge said that one sentence was meant to be an introduction to the main sting in that it was a revelation by former Pandan MP Rafizi Ramly on the misuse of funds.
He said no action had since been filed by Shahrizat in respect of those allegations although a suit was filed against Rafizi for the statements which he had made.
On the defence of justification, Justice Harmindar Singh said Mohamed Salleh failed to disclose his sources of income to finance the purchase of the condominium units apart from making bare assertion as duly noted by the High Court judge.
He said it would not be far-fetched to deduce from the entirety of the evidence at the trial, that there had been misuse of public funds for personal gain.
Lawyers Razlan Hadri Zulkifli and Datuk Joshua Kevin represented Nurul Izzah while lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah appeared for Mohamad Salleh and NFCorp.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Mar 01 2021
Justice Harmindar said the focus of Nurul Izzah's press statement was on the perceived injustice done to those squatters by having to make way with scant compensation.
Kertas kabinet wujud sektor sukan dibentang dalam tempoh sebulan - Hannah
Hannah berkata dengan data yang lebih menyeluruh melibatkan sektor industri sukan nanti, pihaknya akan mampu merangsang pertumbuhan sukan di negara ini dengan lebih baik.
Tiga Syarikat Semikonduktor umum melabur di Pulau Pinang - Kon Yeow
Tiga syarikat semikonduktor dari China menyatakan komitmen untuk membuat pelaburan baharu di Pulau Pinang.
Pindaan garis panduan lawatan: Sekolah diharap susun semula program - Fadhlina
Semua sekolah diharap dapat menyusun semula program lawatan masing-masing berikutan pindaan Garis Panduan Lawatan Murid Sekolah pada tahun lepas bagi mengukuhkan pembelajaran di luar kelas, kata Menteri Pendidikan, Fadhlina Sidek.
Kebajikan pendidikan anak-anak dijaga sehingga tamat sekolah - KPM
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia akan memastikan kebajikan pendidikan anak-anak 10 pegawai dan anggota Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia yang terkorban dalam nahas helikopter di Lumut, Perak, terus dijaga sehingga mereka tamat persekolahan.
Zahid minta pihak dalam BN buka "buku baharu"
Ahmad Zahid menegaskan senario politik tanah air sudah berubah dan terdapat banyak video lama dari parti lawan yang meminta pengundi menyokong DAP.
Malaysia kongsi pengalaman dalam usaha berterusan mempertahan Palestin
Delegasi negara akan berkongsikan peranan Malaysia dalam usaha berterusan mempertahankan nasib Palestin dalam Persidangan Liga Parlimen Al-Quds kelima yang berlangsung di Istanbul, Turki pada Sabtu.
Universiti Malaya mohon maaf kepada seluruh rakyat Malaysia
Jabatan Pengajian Antarabangsa dan Strategik, Universiti Malaya memohon maaf kepada seluruh rakyat Malaysia berhubung kenytaaan tidak bertanggungjawab Profesor Dr Bruce Gilley pada 24 April lalu.
Genting Malaysia nafi terbabit perbincangan
Selepas Berjaya Corporation Bhd dan Kerajaan Negeri Johor, kini Genting Malaysia Bhd pula menafikan sebarang penglibatan dalam perbincangan mengenai pengoperasian kasino di Forest City, Johor.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Sabtu, 27 April 2024.
Lima cedera dalam tembakan di luar kelab malam di Washington
Lima cedera dalam insiden tembakan di luar sebuah kelab malam di Washington, Amerika Syarikat pada lewat Jumaat.
PKR rombak kepimpinan di enam negeri
Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) melakukan rombakan terhadap Majlis Pimpinan Negeri di enam negeri berkuat kuasa serta-merta.
Liyana Marzuki buat laporan polis, nafi jadi proksi Nurul Izzah
Aktivis, Liyana Marzuki membuat laporan polis berhubung dakwaan yang kononnya beliau menjadi proksi gaji bekas Ahli Parlimen Permatang Pauh, Nurul Izzah Anwar.
MoF nafi Nurul Izzah dibayar sebagai penasihat Laksana
MoF menafikan dakwaan Naib Presiden Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR), Nurul Izzah Anwar dibayar sebagai Penasihat kepada Agensi Pelaksanaan Ekonomi dan Koordinasi Strategik Nasional (Laksana).
Hantaran fitnah: Exco AMK lapor polis terhadap Che’gubard
Satu laporan polis dibuat terhadap Chegubard berhubung kenyataan berunsur fitnah membabitkan Naib Presiden PKR, Nurul Izzah Anwar.
"Saya bertanding PRN? Tidak benar!" - Nurul Izzah
Nurul Izzah Anwar menafikan beliau antara calon yang dinamakan untuk bertanding kerusi Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) di Pulau Pinang pada Pilihan Raya Negeri (PRN) yang dijangka diadakan Julai ini.
Shah Firdaus terlepas gangsa, Nurul Izzah pecah rekod kebangsaan
Atlet berbasikal trek negara Muhammad Shah Firdaus Sahrom terlepas peluang membawa pulang pingat gangsa acara pecut individu lelaki Kejohanan Piala Negara-Negara Kesatuan Berbasikal Antarabangsa.
'Berhentilah bermain politik, umpama cakap tak serupa bikin' - Muhyiddin
Henti bermain politik dan elak budaya nepotisme dalam kerajaan, kata Ahli Parlimen Pagoh, Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin.
Nurul Izzah sahkan bukan lagi Penasihat Kanan Ekonomi dan Kewangan Anwar
Naib Presiden PKR, Nurul Izzah Anwar mengumumkan beliau tidak lagi berkhidmat sebagai Penasihat Kanan Ekonomi dan Kewangan kepada Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Anwar pertahan lantikan, tegaskan Nurul Izzah tidak akan salah guna kuasa
Beliau cakna dengan respons daripada rakyat namun sekali lagi menegaskan anaknya itu tidak akan menerima sebarang imbuhan.
Tak salah lantik ahli keluarga jika layak - Mufti Pulau Pinang
Menurut perspektif Islam, dalam menilai sesuatu tindakan atau amalan, sebahagian kita terkeliru antara matlamat dan cara untuk mencapai matlamat.