The first ever Townhall of Auditor General's (AG) Report 2013 was dubbed as groundbreaking and 'the first-of-its kind' with Government officials and media practitioners converging under one roof to iron out issues raised in the AG’s report.
Initiated by the‘transparency’ Minister Datuk Paul Low Seng Kuan and supported by Pemandu and the chief secretary, the Townhall session was attended by director-generals of 24 ministries.
Positive vibes were felt all around, but it leads to several questions: does it really augur well for the country? Are the nation’s leaders ready to rise to the occasion in the ‘greater demand for transparency, openness and accountability” of the 21st century from the public and media practitioners?
Why I think it was good:
1. The townhall is an open platform for government officers to properly rebut damning revelations exposed in the AG’s report and getting them published by media practitioners – whom are often questioned on the matter of their ‘incongruity’ in giving fair portrayals in media reports.
2. Media personnel had a field day, as the event proved to be one-of-a-kind occasion where retaliatory questions can be posed to top government officials. This was one rare occasion where civil servants were supposed to satisfy queries and not escape scrutiny.
3. This is a beginning of a more transparent and accountable government in engaging the public. Is this an indication of the end an era of ‘government knows best’ and ‘government knows and you don’t need to know’.
Here’s how it can be improved:
1. The event chose to confine itself to only one particular AG’s report. The questions posed by the media that was deemed ‘unrelated’ -- even those that were indirectly related, or in one case actually related -- were promptly brushed aside. The government officials should not hide behind caveats to stop being accountable. If boundaries are too narrow, how can the discussions be constructive?
2. It is, indeed encouraging that chief secretary of the government Tan Sri Ali Hamsa assured that such events will be held more frequently. Just how a top editor opined: why stop there? Why not cooperate with the media at all times? Why not pick up calls and respond to emails when pertinent questions are being posed? Could we do away with the culture of ‘sweeping things under the carpet’ and have our top public officials tackling national issues boldly.
3. The event saw the ‘unwelcome’ presence of politicians from the Opposition and civil society known to be critical of the government. Low's decision to politely showing the Pakatan MPs came with the resounding justification, ‘that MPs already have their say heard in Parliament. His point notwithstanding, it leads to the next question: Why is the government so afraid? When will politicians from both opposition and ruling parties start engaging in healthy discourse? If the DGs are ready to face media practitioners, I am sure they are more than capable to not go up against other vocal critics too, including NGOs and civil society.
Is the Government at liberty to choose the time and place or occasion to be accountable to the people the taxpayers?
There’s an old saying that ‘bad habits die hard’ – yet there’s still room for improvement, for the media too. Communication skills and being transparent can be improved tremendously in bringing positive change for the greater glory of the nation – this requires improvement of regulations, procedures as well as work processes.
Because one day we would like to stop repeating this tiresome question: When will we ever learn from the AG’s report?
Teoh El Sen
Thu Jun 19 2014
The chief secretary and other DGs were on stage during the townhall, ready to face almost two hours of grilling by the media.
Serangan ke atas Safiq Rahim tiada kaitan insiden babit dua pemain kebangsaan - Polis Johor
Orang ramai diminta memberi ruang kepada polis untuk menjalankan siasatan termasuk meneliti kamera litar tertutup berdekatan lokasi kejadian.
Jet pejuang F-16 RSAF terhempas, juruterbang diberi rawatan
Menurut kenyataan MINDEF, juruterbang terbabit bertindak mengikut prosedur kecemasan, dan berjaya keluar dari pesawat tersebut.
14 termasuk remaja bawah umur didakwa merusuh dengan parang, anggotai 'Geng 24'
Sekumpulan 14 lelaki termasuk tiga remaja bawah umur didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen Butterworth atas kesalahan merusuh dengan senjata.
Bomba terbangkan kanak-kanak Orang Asli sakit paru-paru dapatkan rawatan
Pesakit mengalami batuk dan selesema berlarutan selama dua hari diiringi ibunya Tini Alang, 34, menaiki pesawat jenis Mi-17-IV.
Mat Yo doa kesembuhan Faisal Halim, sifatkan pemain lincah
Bekas penyerang kebangsaan, Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT) dan Pahang, Norshahrul Idlan Talaha atau lebih dikenali sebagai Mat Yo mendoakan rakan seperjuangannya, Faisal Halim diberi kesembuhan dan dapat beraksi semula di padang di masa akan datang.
Keadaan Faisal Halim semakin baik, tidak sabar kembali berlatih
Keadaan pemain sayap Selangor FC, Faisal Halim semakin baik selepas menjalani pembedahan kedua pada Selasa malam.
[TERKINI] Insiden Safiq tiada kaitan kes Faisal, Akhyar - Polis
Polis percaya insiden serangan kereta permain JDT, Safiq Rahim tiada kaitan dengan dua insiden membabitkan pemain bola sepak sebelum ini iaitu Faisal Halim dan Akhyar Rashid.
Lelaki dipenjara 36 tahun, 40 sebatan rogol anak saudara bawah umur
Mahkamah Sesyen di sini hari ini menjatuhkan hukuman penjara 36 tahun dan 40 sebatan ke atas seorang lelaki atas kesalahan merogol dan melakukan amang seksual terhadap anak saudaranya berusia 14 tahun
Adrain Jerome dilantik sebagai Ahli Jawatankuasa Aduan SPRM
Adrain Jerome Karuna Devan dilantik sebagai Ahli Jawatankuasa Aduan (JKA) Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) yang baharu.
Hakim terkhilaf bebaskan Bung Moktar, Zizie Izette - Pendakwaan
Pendakwaan berkata, hakim itu terkhilaf dalam menjalankan bidang kuasa semakan, selepas keputusan prima facie Mahkamah Sesyen yang memberikan penilaian maksimum di peringkat pendakwaan.
AGC bantah permohonan Syed Saddiq berhubung pemberhentian peruntukan Parlimen Muar
Jabatan Peguam Negara akan membantah permohonan kebenaran semakan kehakiman difailkan Ahli Parlimen Muar Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman serta tiga pihak lain.
Tempoh kuarantin bagi pengembara dikurangkan lima hari - Khairy
Ujian pengesanan COVID-19 RT-PCR perlu dijalankan dua hari sebelum berlepas dengan keputusan negatif COVID-19.
Neelofa, PU Riz tidak dikenakan tuduhan rentas negeri - Pejabat Peguam Negara
Pejabat Peguam Negara membuat keputusan tidak mengenakan tuduhan rentas negeri terhadap pasangan selebriti, Noor Neelofa Mohd Noor dan suaminya, Muhamad Haris Mohd Ismail atau PU Riz.
Memoir Thomas: Azalina gesa peranan AG dan pendakwa raya dipisahkan
Azalina berkata kuasa pendakwaan menjadikan Peguam Negara antara individu paling berkuasa di Malaysia.
Badan kehakiman wajib dilihat bebas, tidak dipengaruhi - Penganalisis
Pelantikan Peguam Negara yang diamalkan sebelum ini memberi persepsi bahawa ada perana Perdana Menteri di dalamnya.
Najib akan failkan saman fitnah terhadap Tommy Thomas, penerbit - Peguam
Perkara itu disahkan oleh peguam bekas perdana menteri Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah.
Wilayah Victoria catat penurunan kes COVID-19
Brett bagaimanapun berkata, penularan wabak itu mungkin akan bertambah buruk tidak dibendung.
Inkues Adib: Tiada siapa bangkitkan isu Syazlin sebelum ini - Zuraida
Tiada pihak yang mempertikaikan pelantikan peguam Syazlin Mansor sebelum ini dalam inkues kematian anggota bomba Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim.
Masuk campur kes Adib: Pembangkang desak AG letak jawatan
Ketua pembangkang, Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob berkata pihaknya turut mendesak supaya Perdana Menteri, Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad memecat Tommy.
Ismail Sabri desak AG letak jawatan
Naib Presiden UMNO itu berkata, banyak pihak terkejut apabila Tommy mengumumkan kos guaman kes kapal mewah Equanimity berjumlah RM2 juta daripada keseluruhan kos berjumlah RM15.5 juta.