Income inequality is a pervasive global issue, and Malaysia is no exception. In this Southeast Asian nation, the middle class finds itself wedged between the affluent elite and the lower-income segments of the population, embodying a metaphorical “sandwich.”
Imagine this scenario: You earn a decent income, enough to afford a comfortable life, but you’re far from being classified as wealthy. This is the situation faced by middle-class individuals in Malaysia, often colloquially known as the M40 group.
However, there’s a twist in their story. Unlike bottom 40% (B40) households, who receive financial aid and support from the government to alleviate their financial hardships, the M40s don’t benefit from these programs. At the same time, they don’t enjoy the same privileges and advantages as the affluent top 20% (T20) segment of society.
It’s like being caught in the middle, trying to make ends meet without the safety net of assistance, yet without the benefits of substantial wealth.
Let’s explore three primary factors contributing to the sensation of being economically sandwiched among the M40 group in Malaysia.
The first key factor contributing to the M40’s economic sandwiching is their exclusion from subsidies and financial assistance originally intended for the B40s.
In Malaysia, rightly so, subsidies and financial assistance programs predominantly target individuals falling below a specified income threshold, particularly the B40 group.
Notwithstanding, as the Government prepares to introduce a targeted subsidy program by next year, the M40s may find themselves excluded from most of these initiatives, thus bearing the full impact of rising prices without government support. This economic challenge further compounds their predicament, as they grapple with the ever-increasing cost of essential commodities.
The second factor is the taxation policies, which play a pivotal role in generating the sense of being “sandwiched” for Malaysia’s M40s.
Like many countries globally, Malaysia employs a progressive income tax system. This progressive structure implies that as individuals earn more income, they are subject to higher tax rates.
The fundamental premise of progressive taxation is to distribute the tax burden equitably, with those earning more contributing a larger share of their income in taxes.
However, in practice, the M40s often finds itself nudged into higher tax brackets. This occurs because their earnings exceed the lowest tax rates but fall short of reaching the income thresholds that would grant them substantial income tax breaks, which are often enjoyed by higher-income individuals.
In concrete terms, according to the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM), as of 2022, an M40 family in Malaysia will have a combined annual income of RM76,056 (monthly median income of RM6,338). In this scenario, a substantial portion of their hard-earned income may be siphoned off in taxes.
This financial allocation to taxes renders financial planning and resource allocation for crucial objectives, such as their children’s education or investments in assets like a home, increasingly challenging.
While grappling with the financial implications of tax allocation, which makes planning for crucial objectives like their children’s education and investments in assets like a home increasingly challenging, the M40s also face third, formidable obstacle—securing affordable housing.
Despite the existence of government initiatives aimed at providing cost-effective housing for low-income families, the M40s are frequently excluded due to their income levels. This exclusion results in a limited range of housing options, often forcing M40 households into expensive private housing or rental accommodations.
These arrangements significantly increase their financial outflows and further intensify their economic squeeze. The M40s are consequently faced with the challenging dilemma of either committing a substantial portion of their income to housing expenses or compromising on their living standards.
Additionally, the burden of education weighs heavily on the M40s. While scholarships and financial aid programs exist for students from the B40 households in Malaysia, M40 households are expected to shoulder most, if not the full burden of tuition fees for their children’s higher education.
This inequality in educational access erects significant barriers to upward mobility and perpetuates the cycle of M40s’ financial strain.
Prosperous M40s, and by extension, middle-income households are essential for a country’s well-being as they contribute to economic stability and growth. Their financial security and disposable income drive consumer spending, which fuels domestic demand and supports various enterprises—especially small and medium ones, thereby fostering economic expansion and job creation.
Robust middle-income households also enhance social cohesion by reducing income inequality, promoting a more equitable society, and reducing the strain on social safety nets.
For instance, countries like Germany, known for its prosperous middle class, have a strong manufacturing base, a well-functioning social safety net, and a high level of economic competitiveness. Similarly, Canada’s middle class has contributed to its economic stability and high standard of living, thanks to a combination of factors like resource wealth and a focus on education and social welfare.
Addressing M40s’ predicament necessitates a concerted effort through progressive taxation reforms, targeted subsidies that are going to be enjoyed by the M40s too, and enhanced access to affordable housing and education.
By doing the above, the M40s can be empowered to navigate a path toward prosperity and no longer feel perpetually trapped in the economic “sandwich.”
Dr Mohd Zaidi Md Zabri is a Senior Lecturer at the Department of Finance, Faculty of Business and Economics, Universiti Malaya, and may be reached at [email protected].
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
AWANI Columnist
Mon Oct 09 2023
The first key factor contributing to the M40s economic sandwiching is their exclusion from subsidies and financial assistance originally intended for the B40s. - Pic via Dr Mohd Zaidi Md Zabri
Apple Pencil baharu hadir dengan sistem haptik
Apabila digunakan pada skrin iPad, pengguna boleh merasakan tindak balas haptik seakan menggunakan pensel sebenar.
[TERKINI] KPM giat laksana pelbagai inisiatif bagi reformasi pendidikan negara
KPM berkata, Laporan Bank Dunia bertajuk 'Bending Bamboo Shoots: Strengthening Foundation Skills' berkenaan sistem pendidikan negara diambil perhatian.
Tentera AS edar gambar jeti maritim Gaza siap dibina
Beberapa gambar pembinaan jeti maritim oleh tentera Amerika Syarikat (AS) di Gaza untuk menghantar bantuan kemanusiaan telah diedarkan Komando Pusat AS pada Isnin.
Pesara tentera maut dilanggar lori menggelongsor
Orang ramai yang mempunyai maklumat berhubung kejadian diminta menyalurkan maklumat berkenaan kepada pegawai penyiasat kes.
Kenaikan cukai perkhidmatan 8% beri kesan kos operasi, unjuran pendapatan Nestle Malaysia dikurangkan
Perbelanjaan operasi bagi 2024 juga diramal bertambah lagi susulan rasionalisasi bahan api yang berkemungkinan dilaksanakan.
Dua sahabat maut dilanggar bas
Mangsa maut di tempat kejadian akibat kecederaan parah di bahagian kepala.
25 terbunuh bas terjunam gaung di utara Peru
Bas antara negeri itu membawa 50 penumpang apabila insiden itu berlaku kira-kira 10.10 malam waktu tempatan.
Jepun, Uzbekistan berentap final Piala Asia B-23
Pasukan yang kalah dalam penentuan tempat ketiga itu akan menentang Guinea yang berada pada kedudukan keempat.
Che'gu Bard tiba di Mahkamah Sesyen Johor Bahru berdepan tuduhan lagi
Beliau yang hadir bersama peguamnya, Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, dijangka berdepan satu lagi pertuduhan mengikut Akta Hasutan 1948.
Niaga AWANI: KWSP: Melestari kehidupan persaraan
Kumpulan Wang Simpanan Pekerja (KWSP) dikatakan bukan satu-satunya organisasi yang bertanggungjawab dari segi menambah baik kehidupan masyarakat. Namun KWSP telah memperkenalkan Akaun Fleksibel dan berkuat kuasa mulai 11 Mei 2024. Bagaimana pengurusan persaraan selepas ini dan apakah pendekatan terbaik bagi meningkatkan literasi kewangan dalam kalangan masyarakat?
Johor terus bantu golongan M40 untuk miliki rumah menerusi Eco Botanic 3
Projek tersebut yang akan dibangunkan secara berfasa oleh pemaju utama EcoWorld, akan menawarkan 3,746 unit rumah.
Belanjawan 2024: PKIBM cadang pembiayaan penuh PTPTN bagi pelajar M40
Persatuan Kebangsaan IPTS Bumiputera Malaysia (PKIBM) menyarankan agar kadar pembiayaan penuh 100 peratus pinjaman Perbadanan Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional (PTPTN) diperluas kepada semua pelajar.
Sebahagian M40 dijangka tidak terima subsidi bahan api - Kenanga Research
Kenanga Research menjangkakan sebahagian kumpulan M40 mungkin tidak akan menerima bahan api bersubsidi selepas pengenalan sistem subsidi bersasar dan sekali gus mengurangkan kuasa membeli mereka.
Kerajaan tidak pernah abaikan M40 - PM Anwar
Beliau berkata dakwaan beberapa pihak bahawa pendekatan kerajaan lebih tertumpu kepada golongan B40 sehingga mengabaikan kumpulan yang berpendapatan sederhana itu adalah tidak tepat.
CUEPACS cadang kenaikan dua peratus pencen pesara kekal
CUEPACS mencadangkan kenaikan pencen pesara kerajaan sebanyak dua peratus setiap tahun dikekalkan sehingga kerajaan melaksanakan pelarasan gaji baharu penjawat awam.
TWL Holdings Bhd bangunkan tanah, majukan rumah mampu milik untuk keperluan rakyat
TWL Holdings Berhad memandang serius isu gelandangan di Malaysia sekali gus berhasrat untuk membendung masalah ini dengan menyediakan penyelesaian dinamik sebelum ia memburuk.
Belanjawan 2023: Kadar cukai pendapatan M40 dikurangkan
Kerajaan bersetuju mengurangkan kadar cukai pendapatan individu kumpulan M40 bagi menambah pendapatan boleh guna golongan terbabit.
Berita baik berkaitan telekomunikasi menjelang Krismas untuk B40, M40
Terdapat permintaan di media sosial supaya beberapa perkara perlu diteliti dari segi kos dan mutu perkhidmatan.
Dilema M40, siapa mahu tolong?
Dalam lautan boleh diduga, dalam hati siapa tahu...
Bajet 2023: Kadar cukai pendapatan individu dikurangkan dua mata peratusan
Hampir satu juta pembayar cukai individu pemastautin bakal menikmati pengurangan cukai dalam usaha kerajaan menambah pendapatan boleh guna yang boleh dimanfaatkan oleh golongan M40.