KUALA LUMPUR: The Sessions Court today granted Lim Guan Eng's application to obtain a forensic report of WhatsApp conversations between two businessmen in a corruption case involving the former Penang Chief Minister.
Judge Azura Alwi made the decision after finding that there were two different testimonies in two courts involving the same payment voucher and cheque as to who received the RM2 million and the purpose of the payment.
Azura said based on the notes of proceedings and written statements of the witnesses in Shah Alam court, that had been produced as exhibits in the application, the court found that the applicant (Lim) had successfully proved the fact that payment vouchers and Public Bank cheques were used to withdraw the RM2 million, which was said to have been handed over to businessman G. Gnanaraja.
"In the case before this court (Sessions Court), the evidence also showed that the same payment voucher and cheque had also been submitted and had been marked as exhibits P140 and P141, and that the RM2 million was said to have been handed over to the accused (Lim).
"The evidence also showed that there was a discussion about the money (RM2 million) through a WhatsApp conversation between Consortium Zenith Construction Sdn Bhd (CZCSB) director Datuk Zarul Ahmad Mohd Zulkifli and Gnanaraja," she said.
Azura said there was also a digital forensic analysis report prepared by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) regarding the WhatsApp conversation that was submitted before the court here.
"However, the digital forensic analysis report produced in the Shah Alam court case, which was requested by the applicant was never submitted to this court," she said.
In this regard, Azura said the matter was a relevant issue according to Sections 5 and 11 of the Evidence Act 1950 where comprehensive facts must be presented and submitted to the court so that the truth can be known.
"The applicant needs to get the digital forensic analysis report and the complainant's report in the Shah Alam Court case to provide a fair defence. The court agreed and found that the principles of equality and fair trial as enshrined in Article 5 and Article 8 of the Federal Constitution will be achieved by allowing this application.
"Following that, the applicant has successfully demonstrated to the court why the forensic report is necessary and important to the defence and the application under Section 51 of the Criminal Procedure Code should be allowed," said the judge.
After the decision, Deputy Public Prosecutor Datuk Wan Shaharuddin Wan Ladin said the prosecution would make the report available to the defence in two weeks time.
Azura then fixed May 10 for mention pending the handover.
The forensic report involved WhatsApp exchanges between Gnanaraja and Zarul Ahmad about the gifting of 'RM2 million chocolate' allegedly given to Lim as a bribe.
The exchanges were previously revealed through the testimony of the MACC forensic investigating officer Assistant Superintendent Wan Mohd Firdaus Wan Yusof.
Lim, 61, is facing an amended charge of using his position as the chief minister of Penang to accept a bribe of RM3.3 million in helping a company owned by Zarul Ahmad to obtain a construction project worth RM6,341,383,702 at the Office of the Chief Minister of Penang, 28th Floor, Komtar, George Town between January 2011 and August 2017.
For the second amended charge, Lim is accused of soliciting a bribe from Zarul Ahmad, namely 10 per cent of the company's profits, as an inducement for obtaining the project and is accused of committing the act near The Gardens Hotel, Lingkaran Syed Putra, Mid Valley City here in March 2011.
Lim also faces two charges of causing two plots of land worth RM208.8 million owned by the Penang government to be disposed of to two companies allegedly linked to the undersea tunnel project.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Apr 05 2023
Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng with his wife Betty Chew (left) at the Kuala Lumpur Court Complex here today. - BERNAMA
AWANI Ringkas: Culan bayar cukai LHDN | Penjenamaan semula
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Kontrak Projek Central Spine Road bernilai RM232 juta diberi kepada Nepturis - Saksi
Berkenaan projek-projek di bawah program Jana Wibawa, Mohamed Fauzi memaklumkan pihak KKR tidak menentukan sebarang projek untuk dimasukkan ke dalam program berkenaan.
Sultan Nazrin dilantik Pengerusi MKI bagi tempoh dua tahun
Sultan Perak Sultan Nazrin Shah dilantik sebagai Pengerusi Majlis Kebangsaan Bagi Hal Ehwal Agama Islam Malaysia (MKI) bagi tempoh dua tahun berkuat kuasa 9 Mac 2024 hingga 8 Mac 2026.
Fungsi JAKIM, Kementerian Perpaduan Negara berbeza - Mohd Na'im
Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Hal Ehwal Agama) Datuk Mohd Na'im Mokhtar menegaskan fungsi Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) adalah berbeza dengan Kementerian Perpaduan Negara (KPN).
Wira negara, damailah anda di sana
Satu negara bersimpati, bersedih dengan perginya pejuang yang telah banyak berjasa buat Malaysia. Bingkisan ini, istimewa buat semua wira yang kini berada di negara abadi.
Indeks utama Bursa Malaysia turun 0.42 peratus susulan pengambilan untung
Pada 5 petang, FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI (FBM KLCI) turun 6.69 mata atau 0.42 peratus kepada 1,575.97 daripada paras penutup 1,582.66 pada Isnin.
Lelaki berpedang serang orang awam di London, lima cedera
Dalam insiden yang berlaku pada jam 7 pagi waktu tempatan, lima mangsa termasuk dua pegawai polis dikejarkan ke hospital berdekatan susulan serangan berkenaan.
Letusan Gunung Ruang: Operasi Lapangan Terbang Sam Ratulangi dihentikan sementara
Abu akibat letusan itu memenuhi kawasan lapangan terbang, dengan penumpang dilihat memakai topeng muka.
‘Saya berdoa agar tuhan satukan kami'
Kelahirannya di dunia disambut tanpa pelukan erat kedua orang tuanya. Kezaliman berterusan tentera rejim zionis sekaligus mengubah takdir hidup bayi Palestin yang diberi nama Yehia Hamuda ini. Malah dia yang belum mengenal erti dunia, kini dilindungi di hospital al-Emirati di Rafah.
Kastam patahkan hampir 2,000 cubaan menyeludup, sita barangan bernilai RM350 juta setakat Mac
Jabatan Kastam Diraja Malaysia (JKDM) berjaya mematahkan 1,856 cubaan penyeludupan melibatkan pelbagai barangan membabitkan nilai cukai RM350 juta setakat Mac lepas.
Projek terowong: SPRM jalankan siasatan khas terhadap Lim Guan Eng - Saksi
Saksi utama pendakwaan kes rasuah Lim Guan Eng memberitahu beliau tidak mendedahkan nama bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang itu semasa memberi keterangan kepada SPRM.
Kes rasuah: Nama Guan Eng timbul selepas kes Gnanaraja disiasat - Saksi
Seorang saksi mengaku di mahkamah bahawa nama Lim Guan Eng hanya ditimbulkan selepas lebih setahun kes rasuah membabitkan seorang ahli perniagaan di Shah Alam, disiasat.
Ahli Parlimen cadang kerajaan teliti impak cukai kepada rakyat
Kerajaan dicadang meneliti pelaksanaan cukai di dalam negara termasuk peningkatan kadar baharu cukai perkhidmatan yang berkemungkinan memberi kesan secara langsung kepada rakyat.
Saksi akui tidak beritahu SPRM RM2 juta untuk Lim Guan Eng
Menurut saksi, beliau tidak pernah menyatakan wang RM2 juta bertujuan diberikan kepada bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang itu.
Saksi tidak sebut nama Guan Eng dalam siasatan kes rasuah terowong dasar laut pada 2018
Seorang saksi utama pendakwaan mengakui bahawa beliau tidak pernah memberitahu SPRM pada 2018 bahawa rasuah RM2 juta ditujukan untuk bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang Lim Guan Eng.
RM247 juta kos penuh projek Gurney Bay - Chow
Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang Chow Kon Yeow menyangkal dakwaan bahawa Fasa 1 Gurney Bay melibatkan kos sebanyak RM247 juta.
Rasuah terowong dasar laut: Pernyataan saksi diserah kepada Guan Eng
Mahkamah Sesyen membenarkan sebahagian dokumen pernyataan saksi utama dalam perbicaraan kes rasuah projek terowong dasar laut diserahkan kepada pembelaan Guan Eng.
Guna air simpanan untuk minum dan masak, air tangki tidak sesuai - Guan Eng
Orang ramai perlu mengambil maklum mengenai air yang disediakan di tangki simpanan tetap tidak sesuai untuk tujuan minuman dan memasak.
Guan Eng cadang peruntukan semua ADUN k'jaan dinaik kepada RM800,000 setahun
Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Air Putih Lim Guan Eng memohon kepada kerajaan supaya peruntukan RM500,000 setahun untuk kesemua ADUN kerajaan ditambah kepada RM800,000, sama seperti di Selangor.
PDC tidak beri tanah kepada swasta untuk dibangunkan - Chow
Bank tanah perindustrian PDC terletak di lokasi strategik dan dapat dipasarkan kepada pelabur kategori industri digalakkan.