ON April 24, 2013, a clothing factory complex near Bangladesh's capital collapsed, killing at least 1,138 workers.
The disaster at Rana Plaza outside Dhaka was one of the world's worst industrial tragedies and highlighted the failure of many top Western fashion brands to protect workers in the poorer countries where their goods are made.
It sparked outrage and calls for change, putting pressure on multinational companies to confront the human cost of their business models and abysmal working conditions.
Ten years later, global fashion companies say they have made progress but rights groups are still calling for robust legal measures to hold them accountable.
The European Union is working on legislation which would target human and social rights abuses, as well as environmental damage by European companies in their production chain.
The bloc's plans are inspired by a pioneering French law, explained Catherine Dauriac, president of Fashion Revolution France, part of an international collective founded after the disaster.
She said the catastrophe was the catalyst for the 2017 law on corporate duty of care, which compels companies to avoid grave harm to human rights, health, safety and the environment.
Rights groups have since launched legal proceedings against several firms, but there have been disappointing results so far.
A first court decision in February dismissed a case brought by several NGOs which had hoped to suspend a controversial TotalEnergies oil megaproject in Uganda and Tanzania.
- Factory safety -
In Bangladesh, a month after the disaster, unions and multinationals signed an agreement on monitoring safety in clothes factories.
The deal now also extends to Pakistan.
With backing from the UN's International Labour Organization, it means around 200 firms including H&M, Primark, Uniqlo and Zara must fund an independent factory inspection system, explained Nayla Ajaltouni of the group Ethics on the Label.
Since 2014, around 1,600 factories in Bangladesh have been renovated, Ajaltouni said.
But some major groups have not signed up including Amazon, Ikea, Levi's and Walmart, she said.
Zara's parent company, the Spanish group Inditex, has around 930,000 local company employees working for it.
It said it had conducted audits among suppliers before the disaster and has accelerated evaluation procedures since.
It added that, like H&M and Uniqlo, it did not have a workshop in Rana Plaza.
Swedish giant H&M Group said that since 2013 it had "disclosed details of manufacturing factories, mills and yarn producers in its public supplier list to further accelerate transparency within its global supply chain".
Japan's Uniqlo said that after the disaster, "we immediately launched our own investigation into fire and building safety at the facilities run by our manufacturing partners in Bangladesh, working with an independent third party".
It also referred to a training program launched with the support of UN Women in 2019 for women in Bangladesh seeking to become leaders at work.
Ireland's Primark said it set up a compensation programme for hundreds of its suppliers' workers after the disaster and continues to provide financial support -- "over $14 million to date".
The company says it conducted or commissioned 2,400 audits in 2021.
- Ultra-fast fashion -
But a "massive recourse to social audits" has "limits", warned Laura Bourgeois, in charge of litigation and advocacy at the non-governmental organisation Sherpa.
She pointed to the financial link between the auditor and the multinational commissioning the audit.
She also criticised "interviews between auditors and workers organised on the spot or in the presence of the manager" and even "rigged audits with factories that have been set up from scratch".
She said there was also a gap between the announcement of an audit and the corrective measures actually taken.
For Ajaltouni, the emergence of ultra-fast fashion and ever lower prices is "a sign of the failure of corporate social responsibility".
Shein is often cited as an illustration of the lack of regulation in fashion. Founded in China and now headquartered in Singapore, the online retailer that gives fast fashion brands a run for their money with its very cheap clothes is regularly questioned over its manufacturing conditions.
It did not respond to AFP's request for comment.
Sandra Cossart, executive director at Sherpa, criticised companies that "appear to be respectful" but devote their resources to getting around legislation.
"They have become aware" they have to change, but legally, it "is still premature to say" that such firms are more responsible now.
ETX Studio
Mon Apr 24 2023
A clothing factory complex near Bangladesh's capital collapsed, killing at least 1,138 workers, April 24, 2013. - ETX Studio
Polis Israel guna meriam air leraikan protes antikerajaan
Penunjuk perasaan menggesa Perdana Menteri Benjamin Netanyahu berundur dan mengadakan pilihan raya baharu.
Rejim Zionis mara ke Jabalia, antara kem pelarian terbesar
Lokasi operasi rejim itu tertumpu di Jabalia, salah satu daripada lapan kem pelarian terbesar di Semenanjung Gaza.
[LAPOR LANGSUNG] Suspek serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram tiada kaitan kumpulan pengganas - KPN
Berita terkini insiden serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram yang mengorbankan dua anggota polis dan mencederakan seorang yang lain, pada Sabtu.
Filem terbaharu ‘The Experts’ tampil pelakon hebat, genre berlainan buat peminat
Filem dengan idea original ini menampilkan kisah fiksyen tentang rompakan yang melibatkan sebentuk cincin permata.
Dua tahun di Ulu Tiram, pulang ke sini jasad terbujur kaku’ - Bapa
Dia tidak menitiskan air mata sepanjang berada di Johor Bahru bagi menyelesaikan urusan jenazah anak keempat daripada lapan itu.
Malaysia, Uzbekistan akan tingkatkan kerjasama ekonomi - Tengku Zafrul
Malaysia dan Uzbekistan akan memperbaharui komitmen mereka untuk mengukuhkan hubungan ekonomi sempena hubungan diplomatik selama empat dekad.
Bimbang hilang suami antara faktor wanita tidak jalani saringan kanser
Bimbang kehilangan suami dan menjadi beban kepada keluarga antara faktor menyebabkan ramai wanita di Kelantan tidak menjalani saringan awal kanser yang disediakan LPPKN di negeri ini.
SUKMA-21: Sarawak mahu cipta rekod untuk naik imej sebagai kuasa sukan
Sarawak selaku tuan rumah temasya Sukan Malaysia (SUKMA) edisi ke-21 yang berlangsung bermula 17 Ogos ini, mahu mencipta rekod kejohanan untuk menaikkan imejnya sebagai kuasa sukan di negara ini.
Kelantan warta garis panduan baharu sukan Muay Thai - Exco
Kerajaan Kelantan sudah mewartakan garis panduan baharu berhubung sukan Muay Thai di negeri itu untuk diperkasakan dan dibangunkan semula bagi melahirkan atlet bertaraf dunia.
Pertumbuhan ekonomi rantau APEC dijangka cecah 3.4 peratus pada 2024 - Laporan
Pertumbuhan ekonomi di negara-negara Kerjasama Ekonomi Asia Pasifik (APEC) dijangka mencecah 3.4 peratus pada 2024 dan perlahan kepada 2.9 peratus pada 2025-2026.
Mesir galas jawatan Presiden D8, utamakan PKS dan pertumbuhan berasaskan teknologi
Mesir telah mengambil alih jawatan Presiden Pertubuhan Kerjasama Ekonomi Lapan Negara Membangun (D8) untuk tempoh sehingga akhir 2025, menggantikan Bangladesh.
Lelaki maut dipijak gajah di Gua Musang
Dalam kejadian jam 5 petang itu, mangsa berusia 29 tahun maut di lokasi akibat kecederaan parah.
Suhu cecah 42 celsius, Bangladesh tutup semua sekolah sehingga Sabtu
Untuk rekod, ini merupakan tahun kedua berturut-turut pihak berkuasa Bangladesh mengambil langkah sama akibat cuaca ekstrem.
Umat Islam di Bangladesh, India dan Pakistan mula berpuasa pada Selasa
Arab Saudi mengumumkan anak bulan kelihatan pada Ahad dan Isnin merupakan hari pertama Ramadan.
Bangladesh hantar pulang 330 warga Myanmar
Bangladesh menghantar pulang kira-kira 330 warga Myanmar yang mencari perlindungan di negara itu, di tengah-tengah konflik di sempadan.
Menteri Luar India, Bangladesh bincang situasi di Myanmar
Menteri Luar India dan Bangladesh mengadakan perbincangan berhubung situasi di Myanmar.
Lebih ramai Rohingya lari ke Bangladesh susulan pertempuran etnik di Myanmar
Ramai telah menyeberang ke kem pelarian Rohingya di tenggara Cox's Bazar yang menempatkan kira-kira 1.2 juta komuniti Islam dari Myanmar.
Hari pertama 2024, ratusan warga asing di Brickfields 'digempur' Imigresen
Dalam serbuan itu, seramai 370 warga asing telah diperiksa manakala lebih 100 daripada mereka didapati melakukan kesalahan di bawah Akta Imigresen 1959/63.
1,000 polis serbu 'mini Dhaka'
Seramai 1,000 anggota dan pegawai polis dari Pasukan Gerakan Am (PGA) menggempur 'mini Dhaka' di Jalan Silang di sini, pada Khamis.
Runtuhan gudang: Mangsa tiada caruman Perkeso, KSM akan ambil tindakan terhadap majikan
Kegagalan majikan mendaftar dan membayar caruman pekerja asing itu jelas melanggar Seksyen 6, Akta Keselamatan Sosial Pekerja 1969 (Akta 4).