PUTRAJAYA: The Malaysian Bar today lost its bid to review the Federal Court's decision that it breached its statutory duty when it decided to allow discussions on lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah's conduct when the latter was an ad hoc prosecutor in Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's Sodomy II case.
A three-member panel of the Federal Court led by Justice Datuk Zabariah Mohd Yusof dismissed the Malaysian Bar's review application with no order as to costs after ruling that they were not satisfied that it was a fit and proper case that falls within the limited grounds and exceptional circusmtances which the power of review may be exercised.
The other two judges on the panel were Justices Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah.
In the court's decision, Justice Zabariah said arguments presented before the court appeared to be an appeal against the finding of the earlier Federal Court panel which the present panel was not empowered to do.
"It was not for this Federal Court panel to consider whether the earlier (Federal Court) panel had or had not made the correct decision on the facts and the law," she said, adding that those were matters of opinion and interpretation of the law.
Justice Zabariah said there was no inconsistency in the decision of the earlier Federal Court panel, adding that the earlier panel, in answering the legal question, had resolved the main contention and issue in the case, namely the breach of statutory duty of the Malaysian Bar, and that other issues were not significant to the appeal.
In March 2015, Muhammad Shafee sued the Malaysian Bar, former Attorney-General Tan Sri Tommy Thomas and former Court of Appeal Judge Tan Sri VC George. Both Thomas and George were lawyers at that time.
He claimed that Thomas had published and submitted a motion on Feb 28, 2015 for discussion by the Malaysian Bar annual general meeting (AGM) on March 14 the same year, and the motion was seconded by George.
The motion related to Muhammad Shafee's conduct as deputy public prosecutor in Anwar's sodomy appeal in the Federal Court, claiming that the former (Muhammad Shafee) had violated the legal profession's rules which prohibited lawyers from publicising themselves.
The motion also alleged that Muhammad Shafee had participated in nationwide roadshows with the purpose of insulting a convicted prisoner and for bringing attention to his role in Anwar's conviction.
On May 26, 2016, the High Court dismissed Muhammad Shafee's suit, and he also lost his appeal in the Court of Appeal on Oct 11, 2018, prompting him to bring the matter to the Federal Court.
On Oct 20 last year, the Federal Court allowed Muhammad Shafee's appeal and held that he was entitled to get damages from the Malaysian Bar and ordered the case to be reverted to the High Court for assessment of damages.
In the decision by the earlier Federal Court panel, Justice Abdul Rahman Sebli said the Malaysian Bar committed a far more serious breach of the law when it published the motion on its website and tabled it for resolution at the AGM.
"This is not only illegal but grossly unfair and highly prejudicial to the appellant (Muhammad Shafee) as it amounts to a prejudgment of his guilt ahead of the disciplinary proceedings before the Disciplinary Board," he said.
On Feb 10, 2015, the Federal Court affirmed Anwar's conviction for sodomising his former aide Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan and sentenced him to five years in jail. Anwar, however, was given full pardon by the King on May 16, 2018.
At today's proceedings which were conducted online, lawyer Lambert Rasa-Ratnam represented the Malaysian Bar while Datuk S. Ambiga acted for Thomas and Porres Royan for George. Muhammad Shafee represented himself.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Sep 19 2022
In March 2015, Muhammad Shafee sued the Malaysian Bar, former Attorney-General Tan Sri Tommy Thomas and former Court of Appeal Judge Tan Sri VC George. - BERNAMA/Filepic
AWANI 7:45 [27/04/2024] - Siasatan sama ada Tun M salah guna kuasa | Jangkaan persaingan sengit | FFC umum tangguh misi | Mesyuarat khas dua hari
#AWANI745 malam ini bersama Dzulfitri Yusof;
1. Mokhzani dan Mirzan nafi disiasat SPRM
2. Pertandingan empat penjuru, PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
3. Freedom Flotilla To Gaza ditangguh, delegasi dunia pulang
4. Mesyuarat Khas WEF berlangsung di Arab Saudi, ketika suhu geopolitik semakin panas
1. Mokhzani dan Mirzan nafi disiasat SPRM
2. Pertandingan empat penjuru, PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
3. Freedom Flotilla To Gaza ditangguh, delegasi dunia pulang
4. Mesyuarat Khas WEF berlangsung di Arab Saudi, ketika suhu geopolitik semakin panas
Budak lima tahun cedera jatuh dari tingkat tiga flat
Seorang kanak-kanak perempuan berusia lima tahun cedera selepas dipercayai terjatuh dari tingkat tiga rumahnya di Flat Taman College Height pada Sabtu.
AWANI Ringkas: Kasino di Forest City
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Hamas sudah terima maklum balas Israel mengenai cadangan gencatan senjata
Gesaan dari seluruh dunia untuk satu gencatan senjata semakin meningkat dengan serangan ke atas Gaza kini memasuki bulan ketujuh.
World Economic Forum berbeza dari kelaziman
Lazimnya World Economic Forum (WEF) akan berlangsung setiap musim sejuk di Davos, Switzerland, lokasi lahirnya forum berprestij dunia ini sejak lebih lebih dekad lalu.
Dalam tempoh kira-kira tiga bulan, WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28 hingga 29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
Ia memberi isyarat, kepentingan kestabilan rantau Asia Barat atau timur tengah ini, bukan perakara main-main.
#AWANI745
Dalam tempoh kira-kira tiga bulan, WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28 hingga 29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
Ia memberi isyarat, kepentingan kestabilan rantau Asia Barat atau timur tengah ini, bukan perakara main-main.
#AWANI745
Pemain Astro Kem Badminton 2024 berpeluang berlatih di bawah jurulatih BAM
Wan Wah menjelaskan pemain-pemain yang dipilih akan menjalani latihan intensif itu di Akademi Badminton Malaysia (ABM).
#AWANI745
#AWANI745
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Pengundi perlu pilih kestabilan - Fadillah
Fadillah berkata beliau percaya pengundi di kawasan tersebut, boleh membuat keputusan terbaik untuk menentukan calon paling layak untuk mewakili mereka.
Liga Parlimen Al-Quds: Malaysia gesa satu resolusi penyelesaian isu Palestin dapat dicapai
Malaysia antara lain mendesak Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu (PBB) meluluskan resolusi menghantar tentera pengaman ke Palestin.
Palestin perlukan 14 tahun untuk dibangunkan semula
Jumlah besar runtuhan akibat serangan dilakukan tentera Israel di Semenanjung Gaza mengambil tempoh sekurang-kurangnya 14 tahun untuk dibersihkan.
#AWANI745
#AWANI745
Delegasi seluruh dunia pulang selepas misi ditangguh
Delegasi seluruh dunia dan Malaysia dijangka bergerak pulang ke negara masing-masing dalam waktu terdekat.
Ia selepas Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) mengumumkan penangguhan terbaharu misi Break the Siege Freedom Flotilla to Gaza pada Sabtu.
Rakan setugas Syaff Shukri dan jurukamera Ab Uzza Ab Latiff ada perinciannya.
#AWANI745
Ia selepas Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) mengumumkan penangguhan terbaharu misi Break the Siege Freedom Flotilla to Gaza pada Sabtu.
Rakan setugas Syaff Shukri dan jurukamera Ab Uzza Ab Latiff ada perinciannya.
#AWANI745
1MDB: Muhammad Shafee ditegur hakim kerana bersikap 'keterlaluan'
Ketua peguam bela yang mewakili Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak ditegur apabila dilihat menyerang kredibiliti pengawai penyiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) ketika perbicaraan.
Keputusan permohonan Najib mulakan semakan kehakiman cabar kewujudan Titah Adendum 5 Jun
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur menetapkan 5 Jun untuk memutuskan permohonan kebenaran semakan kehakiman difailkan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak bagi mencabar kewujudan perintah tambahan beliau.
Ada seorang saksi penting dijangka sokong permohonan Najib untuk tahanan di rumah - Shafee
Seorang saksi penting dijangka memfailkan afidavit bagi menyokong permohonan kebenaran Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak untuk memulakan semakan kehakiman.
Shafee alami palpitasi, perbicaraan kes 1MDB Najib tangguh
Perbicaraan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak berhubung kes penyelewengan RM2.3 bilion dana 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) di Mahkamah Tinggi ditangguhkan hari ini.
Najib akan mohon pengampunan kali kedua - Shafee
Peguamnya Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah memaklumkan permohonan itu dibuat disebabkan anak guamnya tidak mendapat keadilan ketika perbicaraan dan proses Lembaga Pengampunan.
Tunggakan cukai: Muhammad Shafee perlu bayar RM5.5 juta kepada LHDN
Peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah diperintahkan oleh Mahkamah Tinggi supaya membayar tunggakan cukai pendapatan lebih RM5.5 juta kepada Lembaga Hasil Dalam Negeri (LHDN).
LHDN peroleh penghakiman terus kes tunggakan cukai Muhammad Shafee
Mahkamah Tinggi membenarkan permohonan LHDN untuk memasukkan penghakiman terus terhadap peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah berkaitan kes tunggakan cukai.
Pendakwaan tarik balik rayuan, keputusan lepas dan bebas Shafee kekal
Penarikan balik rayuan itu bermakna pembebasan Muhammad Shafee dalam keempat-empat kes itu kekal.
Tunggakan cukai pendapatan RM9.41 juta: Shafee, LHDN akan selesai kes
Muhammad Shafee dan LHDN memberitahu Mahkamah Tinggi bahawa, kes tuntutan tunggakan cukai pendapatan, berada dalam proses penyelesaian.
Najib tidak bekerjasama selepas didakwa - Pegawai penyiasat 1MDB
Datuk Seri Najib Razak dikatakan tidak memberi kerjasama ketika disoal siasat berhubung penyelewengan dana 1MDB.