The Syariah High Court here today dismissed an application by Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to initiate 'qazaf' (bearing false witness) proceedings against senior lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, who allegedly defamed him over his sodomy case.
Syariah judge Mohamed Fouzi Mokhtar made the ruling after finding that the court had no jurisdiction to hear the application because sodomy was not included under the qazaf offence.
On June 26 last year, the former opposition leader had filed a qazaf complaint at the Selangor Islamic Religious Department enforcement division here, through his wife Datin Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail, who is also PKR president.
The complaint was made after Muhammad Shafee's action of accusing Anwar of sodomising his former aide, Saiful Bukhari Azlan was made without producing four male witnesses or the oath of the accused (Anwar), as required by syariah law.
In the complaint, Muhammad Shafee was alleged to have made the statement at an open dialogue organised by the Captain Hussein Leadership Academy in Kelana Jaya, Petaling Jaya on Feb 17, 2015.
According to the complaint, the Imam Syafie mazhab (school of thought within Islamic jurisprudence) placed the sodomy under the 'zina' (illicit sexual intercourse) category and a sodomy accusation without producing four male witnesses was a qazaf offence.
Mohamed Fouzi in a 21-page judgment said there was a difference of opinion on whether sodomy could be included as an offence under the zina category or not.
He noted that the Selangor legislative bodies had placed the qazaf offence under Section 36 of the Selangor Syariah Criminal Enactment 1995 but the word 'zina' that was mentioned in the provision (Section 36) was only interpreted as a sexual intercourse between a man and a woman who were not married without placing the sodomy act under it.
"The question is, whether the alleged sodomy act can also be construed as 'zina' based on the views of Islamic scholars? Generally, the Islamic scholars have different opinions regarding this issue, whereby most of them stated that sodomy is included under zina.
"In making the interpretation on zina, lawmakers have taken the views of Imam Abu Hanifah who said that the sodomy act was not a qazaf offence but it was included under the takzir (discretionary punishment)" he said.
Mohamed Fouzi said lawmakers certainly had not been erroneous in making the interpretation because they had chosen to adopt the view that they thought it was appropriate to the current state of society in this country, even if it was not based on the view of the Shafie sect.
He said the court did not deny that the view was a minority but once it was adopted as a law it became strong and should be observed.
Whether the court could extend the interpretation of zina, he said, at the moment, the power of a syariah judge was subject to the jurisdiction which was allocated to him.
"If the court made a decision on a case that is not within its jurisdiction or misinterpreted a provision, the court's decision can be invalid and cannot be executed," he said.
Mohamed Fouzi said whether the court had sufficient reason to approve Anwar's qazaf application against Muhammad Shafee, the court believed that at this stage, the complaints made was not as heavy as to prove that a person was guilty in committing an act.
He then dismissed Anwar's complaint based on Section 76 of the Syariah Criminal Procedure (State of Selangor) Enactment 2003. -- BERNAMA
Bernama
Thu Oct 27 2016
On June 26 last year, Anwar filed a qazaf complaint at the Selangor Islamic Religious Department enforcement division through his wife Datin Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail. - Filepic
Bekas pegawai PTG didakwa tipu status Tanah Rizab Melayu
Rosli Che Mohamed, 64, bagaimanapun mengaku tidak bersalah dan minta dibicarakan selepas pertuduhan dibacakan di hadapan Hakim Datuk Ibrahim Osman.
AWANI Ringkas: Menteri Besar Perlis beri keterangan kepada SPRM
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Lelaki bunuh kekasih terlepas hukuman gantung, ganti jel 30 tahun
Seorang penyelenggara stor yang membunuh teman wanitanya dengan menjerut leher menggunakan kain tudung terselamat daripada tali gantung.
Empat lelaki ditahan bantu siasatan kes gaduh di kuil
Kes disiasat mengikut Seksyen 148 Kanun Keseksaan dan usaha mengesan suspek lain sedang giat dijalankan.
Pencarum perlu upskill dan reskill untuk tingkatkan jumlah wang persaraan - Pakar
Beliau berkongsi pandangan dalam program Niaga AWANI pada Selasa. Antara lain, beliau menasihatkan agar pencarum tingkatkan juga literasi kewangan.
[TERKINI] SPRM sahkan MB Perlis diambil keterangan
Menteri Besar Perlis, Mohd Shukri Ramli hadir memberi keterangan di Ibu Pejabat SPRM di Putrajaya bagi membantu siasatan kes melibatkan anak lelakinya.
Biotoksin masih tinggi, penternak diminta jangan jual kupang - Jabatan Perikanan
Ujian makmal turut mendapati sampel air dan kupang di perairan tersebut dicemari alga spesies 'Alexandrium' yang berbahaya kepada manusia.
Bintang 'Spider-Man' Tom Holland zahir hasrat kahwini aktres Zendaya
Bintang Spider-Man itu dikatakan sudah berbincang dengan Zendaya untuk berkahwin.
Kes lelaki Israel: Kertas siasatan 10 suspek akan dirujuk AGC minggu ini
Datuk Rusdi Mohd Isa berkata, perbincangan akan diadakan bagi membuat keputusan terhadap tindakan lanjut yang akan dikenakan terhadap suspek terlibat.
Raja Charles III kembali jalani tugas awam selepas rawatan kanser
Raja Britain, Raja Charles III kembali menjalankan tugas awam selepas kesan positif rawatan kansernya.
Langkah Dubai: 'Saya tahu, tapi tak boleh 'habaq' - Sanusi
Cakap-cakap politik berkait spekulasi 'Langkah Dubai' hari ini masih lagi kedengaran biar pun tiada sebarang bukti signifikan.
Rombakan Kabinet: Tidak adil buat penilaian dalam tempoh setahun - PM
Menteri atau timbalan menteri harus diberi peluang memperbaiki prestasi mereka termasuk beliau sendiri, kata Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Pentas PBB: Ucapan PM berani, tegas, berpijak pada realiti semasa - Reezal Merican
Pendirian yang ditunjukkan PM adalah jalan yang paling wajar dengan membuktikan tiada hipokrasi.
Ucapan sulung PM sentuh segala isu mustahak dunia - Syed Hamid
Isu-isu sensitif tetapi perlu disentuh seperti di Afghanistan, mencerminkan bahawa pendirian Malaysia adalah amat jelas sekali.
PM selesai jalani pembedahan kecil gigi
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim dalam perkongsian di laman Facebook memaklumkan beliau kini berada dalam pemantauan pihak hospital sehingga esok.
Malaysia bakal tarik lebih banyak syarikat automotif China
Sektor automotif juga perlu memastikan ekosistemnya memenuhi matlamat alam sekitar, sosial dan tadbir urus korporat (ESG) PBB.
PM mahu kesatuan rakyat ditingkatkan sempena Aidilfitri
Beliau turut mengucapkan salam Aidilfitri buat seluruh rakyat Malaysia.
LHDN layak siasat individu, syarikat elak bayar cukai - PM
Perdana Menteri menegaskan, selagi beliau diberikan amanah memimpin negara, beliau akan pastikan setiap individu patuh kepada undang-undang.
Malaysia-UAE sepakat tingkatkan kerjasama pelbagai bidang - PM Anwar
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim berharap akan dapat mengadakan lawatan ke Emiriah Arab Bersatu (UAE) dalam masa terdekat.
PM bertemu Erdogan, zahir solidariti Malaysia kepada Turkiye
Beliau dalam masa turut menyeru agar semua mendoakan peristiwa duka itu segera berlalu dan Turkiye kembali pulih.