I recently proposed the idea of a checklist to evaluate the economic policies that have been coming fast and furiously from both sides of the political divide.
The idea seems to have gained some traction as there has been encouraging feedback and even an invitation to be on a popular radio station.
Now that Barisan Nasional (BN) has unveiled its manifesto, how does it shape up, according to the checklist? Here is my personal take.
The first criterion is practicality. Practicality can mean different things but here, it is whether the policies are actionable rather than just lofty motherhood statements.
On this score, the BN manifesto scores. In all 17 areas covered, there were specifics about what had been done in the past five years and what would be done in the next five, so no problems there.
Of course, one can argue whether these are the right actions to be taken but that is another matter. In general, there needs to be a lot more serious dialogue on the what, how, when and why of projects and programmes.
The second criterion is recognition of interdependencies. A weakness of policy formulation everywhere is that it is often done in 'silos', that is, it does not take into account what is happening and what the needs are elsewhere.
For example, the civil service is certainly a vital institution but how do the vast resources diverted to it, impact the private sector, especially in terms of the availability and cost of a limited pool of manpower?
Also, what are the effects of the large investments in public transportation and other infrastructure, affordable housing and health services on credit markets? What are the effects on the country's external current account balance?
These and other questions are not addressed and the fair thing to say is that the jury is out, and not just on the BN manifesto but also the Pakatan Rakyat's (PR).
A third criterion has to do with incentives, that is, that policies do not reward unproductive and penalise productive behaviour.
Many policies with excellent intentions end up being problems because they create rent-seeking and entitlement mind-sets.
If Malaysia is really to transform, there cannot be deterrents for hard work and wealth accumulation.
For all the fanfare about government cash transfers, the financial assistance offered is really quite reasonable. For the bottom 40 per cent of households, it is roughly equivalent to an extra month's income for them.
The fact that this is in cash and targeted also speaks well of it. The same cannot be said for non-cash and untargeted assistance, namely energy and food subsidies, which lead to distortion and wastage on a massive scale.
It should be pointed out that the other initiatives of the manifesto means that some Malaysians will receive multiple assistance. On the cash grants alone, however, I think the BN manifesto does not quite go overboard and deserves a passing grade.
The fourth criterion is financial sustainability. Economists would not be economists if they did not mention budget constraints. Given the public debt problems faced by many countries, this is not to be taken lightly.
There has already been a lot of debate about whose manifesto is more financially sustainable and I do not intend to reproduce it here.
In my opinion, both the BN and PR versions must do more to show more convincingly that they will not result in massive budget blowouts and borrowing requirements.
Fifth is innovation. Einstein once defined insanity as doing the same things over and over and expecting different results. Can the BN manifesto be accused of doing the same things over and over?
To me, the centrepiece of the manifesto, and the key to achieving all its aspects, is the building of a resilient, dynamic and innovative economy. Without a strong economic base, everything else is just a pipe dream.
If there is one vital difference between the BN to the PR manifesto, it is on the need to be pro-growth and pro-business.
While we already know the pros and cons of the Economic Transformation Programme, we are unsure about the PR's growth strategies.
Sixth is external orientation. If Malaysia is really to be competitive and dynamic, it must liberalise its markets and promote cross-border interactions.
Policies that seek to resist or delay external pressures are extremely suspect.
The BN manifesto clearly states it supports the realisation of the Asean Economic Community and enhancing economic and bilateral interests. (Strangely, this was placed under the Global Movement of Moderates.)
On this, it deserves a grinning thumbs-up. It should be noted though that many countries are also liberalising for reasons of competitiveness and this must be taken into account.
Seventh, and lastly, is social capital and inclusiveness. As befits election manifestos, this is the strong suit of both the BN and PR. Both sides get top scores in my opinion.
Recognising that there is a need to address social justice issues, it is nevertheless, my sincere hope that we do not over-compensate and end up creating a burgeoning welfare state.
Note: Steven Wong is senior director at the Institute of Strategic and International Studies (ISIS Malaysia).
Steven Wong
Fri Apr 12 2013
Lelaki warga Myanmar maut dalam pergaduhan
Seorang lelaki ditemui dalam keadaan tidak sedarkan diri dan berlumuran darah dipercayai ditikam dan dipukul pada bahagian kepala.
Jabatan Pengajian Antarabangsa dan Strategik UM mohon maaf kepada seluruh rakyat Malaysia
Dalam satu kenyataan pada Sabtu, jabatan itu menegaskan pihaknya kesal dan memandang serius terhadap perkara itu.
AWANI 7:45 [27/04/2024] - Siasatan sama ada Tun M salah guna kuasa | Jangkaan persaingan sengit | FFC umum tangguh misi | Mesyuarat khas dua hari
#AWANI745 malam ini bersama Dzulfitri Yusof;
1. Mokhzani dan Mirzan nafi disiasat SPRM
2. Pertandingan empat penjuru, PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
3. Freedom Flotilla To Gaza ditangguh, delegasi dunia pulang
4. Mesyuarat Khas WEF berlangsung di Arab Saudi, ketika suhu geopolitik semakin panas
1. Mokhzani dan Mirzan nafi disiasat SPRM
2. Pertandingan empat penjuru, PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
3. Freedom Flotilla To Gaza ditangguh, delegasi dunia pulang
4. Mesyuarat Khas WEF berlangsung di Arab Saudi, ketika suhu geopolitik semakin panas
Piala Thomas: Jangan pandang mudah Malaysia - Antonsen
Walaupun Malaysia membariskan skuad perseorangan kurang 'menyengat', Anders Antonsen masih menjangkakan saingan sengit.
Budak lima tahun cedera jatuh dari tingkat tiga flat
Seorang kanak-kanak perempuan berusia lima tahun cedera selepas dipercayai terjatuh dari tingkat tiga rumahnya di Flat Taman College Height pada Sabtu.
AWANI Ringkas: Kasino di Forest City
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Hamas sudah terima maklum balas Israel mengenai cadangan gencatan senjata
Gesaan dari seluruh dunia untuk satu gencatan senjata semakin meningkat dengan serangan ke atas Gaza kini memasuki bulan ketujuh.
World Economic Forum berbeza dari kelaziman
Lazimnya World Economic Forum (WEF) akan berlangsung setiap musim sejuk di Davos, Switzerland, lokasi lahirnya forum berprestij dunia ini sejak lebih lebih dekad lalu.
Dalam tempoh kira-kira tiga bulan, WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28 hingga 29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
Ia memberi isyarat, kepentingan kestabilan rantau Asia Barat atau timur tengah ini, bukan perakara main-main.
#AWANI745
Dalam tempoh kira-kira tiga bulan, WEF keluar dari kelazimannya dengan menganjurkan mesyuarat khas dua hari, 28 hingga 29 April 2024 di Riyadh, Arab Saudi.
Ia memberi isyarat, kepentingan kestabilan rantau Asia Barat atau timur tengah ini, bukan perakara main-main.
#AWANI745
Pemain Astro Kem Badminton 2024 berpeluang berlatih di bawah jurulatih BAM
Wan Wah menjelaskan pemain-pemain yang dipilih akan menjalani latihan intensif itu di Akademi Badminton Malaysia (ABM).
#AWANI745
#AWANI745
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Pengundi perlu pilih kestabilan - Fadillah
Fadillah berkata beliau percaya pengundi di kawasan tersebut, boleh membuat keputusan terbaik untuk menentukan calon paling layak untuk mewakili mereka.
Bukan koman-koman, PRK Kemaman disifatkan ''battle of honour''
Pilihan Raya Kecil Kemaman disifatkan sebagai battle of honour yang menjadi medan penting untuk menilai dinamik dan landskap politik negara.
PRK Pelangai: Peluang PN, BN menang setara - Takiyuddin
Takiyuddin optimis PN mempunyai kelebihan, impak daripada strategi pecutan akhir yang dilakukan parti itu.
Kalau BN kalah PRK Pelangai, PH kena bertanggungjawab - Mohamad Sabu
Menjadi tanggungjawab jentera PH memastikan kemenangan calon BN di PRK Pelangai.
PRK Pelangai: Bapa ingatkan Amizar jangan tabur janji bulan bintang
"Usah berjanji bulan bintang semata-mata untuk meraih undi", itu pesan bapa kepada calon Barisan Nasional (BN) pada Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Pelangai Datuk Amizar Abu Adam.
BN hilang 27,000 undi Melayu pada PRK - Isham Jalil
BN kehilangan 27,000 undi Melayu pada Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Parlimen Pulai dan Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Simpang Jeram yang berlangsung pada Sabtu.
PRK: PH mungkin hilang Simpang Jeram jika undi BN beralih - KJ
Khairy Jamaluddin tidak menolak kemungkinan Pakatan Harapan (PH) hilang kerusi Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Simpang Jeram.
'UMNO bertanding sendiri, itu pandangan peribadi saya' - Azalina
Azalina berkata, kenyataannya berkenaan UMNO boleh menimbang bertanding atas tiket sendiri pada pilihan raya selepas ini berbanding menggunakan logo BN adalah pandangan peribadinya.
Pasca PRN Selangor: Perang sudah tamat, kini masa berkhidmat untuk rakyat
Persoalan siapa memiliki 56 kerusi Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) dalam Pilihan Raya Negeri (PRN) Selangor telah berakhir dan mandat telah diberikan rakyat kepada pemimpin yang dipilih.
Saarani nafi keluar kenyataan ada perubahan 'besar' jika BN tidak diangkat MB Negeri Sembilan
Saarani berkata perbuatan mewujudkan kenyataan palsu itu langsung tidak membawa sebarang manfaat kepada negara serta rakyat.
Usaha PM bangunkan negara tidak harus ternoktah dengan keputusan PRN - Pemuda UMNO Kota Raja
Mohd Zaffarollah menegaskan biarpun UMNO mengalami kekalahan teruk, namun ia tidak seharusnya mengubah apa-apa keputusan menyertai Kerajaan Perpaduan.