After a string of scandals and embarrassments, Uber's embattled CEO Travis Kalanick was forced to resign. The assumption is that he was pushed out for bad behavior. The truth is more prosaic. The other problems compounded the basic one: He lost a lot of money. Uber lost $2.8 billion on $6.5 billion of revenue in 2016.
Many years ago, Fred Wilson, one of the top venture capitalists in the world, famous for his role in companies such as Twitter and Zynga, put it succinctly: "VCs have control when things don't work. Entrepreneurs have control when they do." That's common sense in most of the business world. But as the Uber debacle shows, legal provisions such as board seats or shareholder voting rights matter much less than actual performancein Silicon Valley too.
The prevailing mythos of Silicon Valley says that it is visionary founder-CEOs -- think Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Mark Zuckerberg -- who create great companies and need to be insulated to work their magic. Venture capitalists and money men, the thinking goes, would otherwise get legal control of the company, oust the great founders and lead companies to their doom. Founders should be allowed to retain legal control of the company, something that, in a highly competitive Silicon Valley funding environment, many VCs have agreed to.
And yet, Kalanick, one of those visionary founders, was just ousted from the company despite having a great deal of control. One of Uber's key investors, Benchmark Capital's Bill Gurley, a legendary venture capitalist, seems to have played a crucial role in Kalanick's ouster, even though technically he did not have the authority on the board to fire him.
Kalanick controlled the majority of seats on Uber's board, as well as a majority of voting rights for shareholders. However, that ended up not meaning much: Uber, which is losing money by the bucketful, arguably a necessary move to build a network effect which will reap profits later, needs investors. Having the majority voting rights in a company that gets shunned by investors because you're reckless is not worth a lot.
Steve Jobs never had formal legal control at Apple. He was ousted from the company in the 1980s because the visionary products he shepherded -- the Apple Lisa desktop computer and then the Mac -- were commercial failures. When he returned to the company in 1998, he put out a string of highly successful products -- first the iMac, then the iPod, and of course the iPhone -- that brought the company back from the brink and then ensured strong profitable growth; his leadership was never subsequently questioned.
Facebook has had various growing pains as a fledgling social network, but its user numbers and revenue never stopped growing. If the company had a MySpace-like trajectory, it is unlikely that Zuckerberg's formal legal control of the company's board and shareholder voting rights would have protected him from investor pressure to make radical changes, up to stepping down. Many have fretted about the corporate governance implications of Snapchat going public by releasing only non-voting stock to the public; but if the company ends up cratering CEO Evan Spiegel is likely to be outgoing. Similarly Rupert Murdoch was able to survive phone-tapping scandals in the U.K. and the problems at Fox in large part because of the robust results he continued to generate for News Corp.
Some companies can lose money but still do well because they're growing, capturing markets and building strategic advantage. Uber is not only losing money -- and it's burning through cash at an enormous rate -- but clearly it is also going through a crisis, with executive turnover, a stalled self-driving car project, myriad lawsuits and other problems.
Meanwhile, Microsoft is one of the most profitable companies on Earth, but it is growing tepidly and is getting outplayed by competitors in its most strategic markets. Its co-founder and CEO Steve Ballmer was not brutally defenestrated, but he was certainly nagged to pass on the reins by board members and investors until he felt he had to go. It seems obvious that if Microsoft under Ballmer had beaten Google in search, Apple in mobile and Amazon in cloud, he would be CEO of Microsoft today, and would be globally lauded as a turnaround artist.
As an Uber watcher (and mostly satisfied customer) Kalanick's ouster feels bittersweet. Uber's aggressive, macho culture caused problems; but it also seems clear that without it Uber would never have managed to become the behemoth it is today, one which has changed transportation forever, and that culture came from Kalanick. His ouster is another reminder that meteoric growth and arresting vision is never enough. A CEO who is making a healthy profit for his firm has a secure position; but, even in Silicon Valley, a company that needs investors to stay afloat will sacrifice a founder if needed, whatever the company's by-laws.
The Washington Post
Sat Jun 24 2017
He lost a lot of money. Uber lost $2.8 billion on $6.5 billion of revenue in 2016.
Niaga AWANI: Bursa Malaysia dijangka diniagakan dalam jajaran kecil minggu ini
Naib Presiden Penyelidikan Ekuiti Rakuten Trade Sdn Bhd, Thong Pak Leng berkata beliau meramalkan paras sokongan segera pada 1,555, diikuti dengan 1,545.
Niaga AWANI: Cabaran jurang negara kaya dan membangun
Editor Astro AWANI, Najib Aroff menemu bual Mirek Dusek yang merupakan Pengarah Urusan, World Economic Forum (WEF) berkait fokus serta tumpuan Mesyuarat Khas WEF serta jurang negara kaya dan membangun.
AWANI Pagi: Sokongan & peluang pekerjaan untuk komuniti Autistik
Sempena sambutan Bulan Autisme Sedunia pada April, ikuti diskusi bersama Beatrice Leong, Autistik, Aktivis dan Pengasas Persatuan Kesejahteraan Autisme mengenai ekosistem sokongan untuk pekerjaan individu autistik di Malaysia.
Letupan bom Sungai Golok: Penduduk Rantau Panjang turut rasai gegaran
Selain letupan seorang saksi mendakwa turut mendengar insiden berbalas tembakan di kawasan berkenaan.
Niaga AWANI: FOMC Mei 2024 bermula esok, apakah jangkaan keputusan The Fed?
Pasaran kini menjangkakan kadar faedah akan dikekalkan pada mesyuarat Jawatankuasa Pasaran Terbuka Persekutuan (FOMC) seterusnya iaitu pada 1 Mei ini. Adakah ini akan menepati jangkaan pasaran? Perbincangan bersama Ketua Ekonomi, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd, Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid.
Delegasi Hamas ke Kaherah bincang gencatan senjata
Hamas dijangka bertindak balas terhadap cadangan genjatan senjata berperingkat terbaharu Israel yang disampaikan pada Sabtu lalu.
14 rumah terjejas ribut landa Kuala Muda
Antara kawasan lain yang terlibat ialah Kampung Teluk Wang Besar, Kampung Teluk Wang Kechil, Kampung Bukit dan Kampung Masjid.
Manfaatkan teknologi AI dalam sektor pendidikan
Perbincangan diperlukan mengenai cara-cara untuk mengintegrasikan AI ke dalam sistem pendidikan secara berkesan.
AWANI Pagi: Berita tumpuan & menarik di astroawani.com [29 April 2024]
Antara fokus Awani Pagi bersama Geegee Ahmad & Afiezy Azaman;
IPR: Peniaga nasi kukus raih jualan RM14,000 sebulan
Waspada ejen nikah Siam
Pindaan Garis Panduan Lawatan: Sekolah diharap susun semula program – Fadhlina
IPR: Peniaga nasi kukus raih jualan RM14,000 sebulan
Waspada ejen nikah Siam
Pindaan Garis Panduan Lawatan: Sekolah diharap susun semula program – Fadhlina
TotalEnergies setuju tingkat pelaburan di Malaysia - PM
TotalEnergies menyatakan komitmen dan bersetuju untuk mempertingkatkan pelaburan dalam sektor huluan minyak dan gas.
'Bill Gates kenal Dolly Chaiwala, Dolly Chaiwala tak kenal Bill Gates' - Netizen
Gates dipercayai singgah menikmati teh susu Dolly sewaktu hadir ke majlis praperkahwinan anak orang terkaya Asia yang diadakan selama tiga hari di India.
AI akan ubah kehidupan manusia dalam masa lima tahun, kata Bill Gates
Bill Gates percaya sejarah menunjukkan setiap teknologi baharu hadir ketakutan dan menyusul dengan peluang baharu.
Twitter mula buang tanda pengesahan biru, Bill Gates dan Kim Kardashian antara 'mangsa'
Twitter pada Khamis mula membuang tanda pengesahan daripada beribu-ribu akaun, termasuk akaun tokoh terkenal.
Gates syor cipta benih ajaib tangani isu perubahan iklim
Apa yang diperlukan katanya, adalah inovasi dalam teknologi pertanian yang boleh membantu memulihkan krisis tersebut.
MBKM, agensi berkaitan perlu lebih giat majukan industri penerbitan buku - PM
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob mahu budaya membaca dalam kalangan rakyat di negara ini dipupuk secara berterusan.
Amaran Bill Gates tentang wabak, serangan cacar jadi kenyataan
Gates menyarankan pemerintah melabur puluhan bilion dolar untuk R&D yang didakwa bakal menelan kos yang tinggi.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah antara yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Isnin, 9 Mei 2022.
COVID-19: Bill Gates nafi suntikan vaksin boleh jejak manusia
Gates sentiasa menafikannya tetapi penafian yang dilakukan itu belum cukup untuk memadamkan teori tersebut.
COVID-19: Pandemik terburuk, lebih dahsyat mungkin melanda dunia - Bill Gates
Gates beri amaran kemungkinan terdapat varian "lebih mudah tersebar dan lebih berbahaya" berbanding varian Delta dan Omicron."
Bebas karbon: Negara kaya perlu main peranan - Bill Gates
Negara-negara kaya perlu memainkan peranan masing-masing dalam menjayakan penghasilan produk teknologi hijau di peringkat global.