For more than 30 years, sharia courts enforcing Islamic law have been operating quietly across Britain. But two official inquiries have put them in the spotlight amid accusations that they discriminate against women.
Very little is known about them, even their number, which one study by the University of Reading puts at 30, while the British think tank Civitas estimates there are 85.
Sharia courts or councils, as they prefer to be called, mainly pronounce on Islamic divorces, which today constitute 90 percent of the cases they handle.
They range from groups of Muslim scholars attached to a mosque, to informal organisations or even a single imam.
But while they are aimed at helping resolve family and sometimes commercial conflicts within the Muslim community, some stand accused of undermining women's rights.
Campaigners cite instances where courts have refused to grant religious divorces to women who are victims of domestic abuse, and accuse them of legitimising violence, including marital rape.
The government and MPs on parliament's home affairs committee both opened inquiries this year into whether the councils are actually compatible with British law.
They are looking into the function and possible discriminatory practices of the courts.
'Rise of the Islamist movement'
The first sharia court appeared in London in 1982 under the government of Margaret Thatcher, who rolled back state intervention in many areas, including mediation in family conflicts, which was delegated to faith groups.
But religious courts have existed for hundreds of years in Britain, whether in the Catholic Church or in the Jewish community -- the Beth Din -- notes Amin Al-Astewani, lecturer in law at Lancaster University.
As with sharia councils, the decisions of those bodies are not legally binding, but they represent a strong moral and social constraint for those who use them, he wrote in a submission to the parliamentary inquiry.
For Shaista Gohir, the chairwoman of Muslim Women's Network UK who gave evidence to the parliamentary inquiry, sharia councils are useful for Muslims but should be framed by a "strong code of conduct".
She also urged the government to make civil marriage obligatory for couples marrying under Islamic law, to ensure women are legally protected, saying that 40 percent of women who contact her organisation only had religious marriages.
But for other Muslim feminists, the courts constitute a "parallel legal system" and should be banned altogether.
An open letter to this effect was signed by more than 200 national and international women's organisations, while legislation which would limit the scope of sharia councils has been put forward by a member of the House of Lords.
"They are discriminatory, they are abusive, they endorse and legitimise violence," in particular marital rape, Maryam Namazie, spokeswoman for the One Law for All campaign, told AFP.
She added: "These courts are linked to the rise of the Islamist movement. They are now saying that to be a good Muslim you have to go to these courts to get a divorce. It's not the case."
Swiss political commentator Elham Manea, the author of "Women and Sharia Law" who has studied the phenomenon for four years, said the first councils were set up by Islamist groups.
"They have been working with a kind of a tacit approval of British establishment," she told AFP.
"There is a certain kind of hesitancy from British institutions to interfere in what they consider is internal affair to the Muslim community."
It remains to be seen whether the inquiries will change that situation, but they are already having some effect.
The London Central Mosque is attempting to organise the tribunals by bringing them under an umbrella group, the UK Board of Sharia Councils, which currently has 15 members.
AFP
Sun Nov 13 2016

Religious courts have existed for hundreds of years in Britain.

Mangsa banjir di Kelantan terus meningkat malam ini
Jumlah mangsa banjir di Kelantan terus meningkat kepada 4,398 orang daripada 1,405 keluarga setakat 9 malam ini, berbanding 2,632 orang daripada 799 keluarga pagi tadi.

Timbalan Perdana Menteri Timor-Leste tiba untuk lawatan kerja empat hari
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Timor-Leste Francisco Kalbuadi Lay tiba hari ini untuk lawatan kerja empat hari ke Malaysia.

Gunung Marapi di Sumatera Barat meletus, muntahkan abu sejauh 3km
Gunung Marapi, gunung berapi paling aktif di Pulau Sumatera, meletus pada 2.54 petang (waktu tempatan) hari Ahad.
AWANI Ringkas: Bekas menteri kesihatan meninggal dunia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
AWANI 7:45 [3/12/2023] - Banjir di Kelantan memburuk | Tekanan kepada negara maju menyumbang | Pelaksanaan IDN berbeza | Mangsa maut masih di bawah runtuhan
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Luqman Hariz;
Digital ID tidak rakam cap jari, iris pengguna, kerajaan jamin data selamat
Banjir di Kelantan memburuk, mangsa di PPS lepasi 4,000
Lebih 60 peratus kediaman di gaza musnah dibedil zionis sejak 7 Oktober
Saksikan #AWANI745 di saluran 501 Astro Awani, Astro Awani apps dan astroawani.com/live-tv.
Digital ID tidak rakam cap jari, iris pengguna, kerajaan jamin data selamat
Banjir di Kelantan memburuk, mangsa di PPS lepasi 4,000
Lebih 60 peratus kediaman di gaza musnah dibedil zionis sejak 7 Oktober
Saksikan #AWANI745 di saluran 501 Astro Awani, Astro Awani apps dan astroawani.com/live-tv.

BNM, Bank Dunia umum inisiatif untuk sokong hasil positif alam semulajadi
Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) dan Bank Dunia hari ini mengumumkan dua inisiatif utama untuk membolehkan sektor kewangan menyokong hasil positif semula jadi.
The Future Is Female: Women in Science - Women Making Waves in Scientific Discovery
For 25 years, the L’Oréal Foundation and UNESCO have been working together to empower and promote women in science through the ‘For Women in Science’ programme. Malaysia has been part of the programme for the last 18 years, during which over RM1.5 million in research grants have been awarded to more than 51 women scientists in recognition of their achievement in science. On this episode of #TheFutureIs Female Melisa Idris speaks to this year’s Malaysian beneficiaries: Dr Acga Cheng from UM, Dr Che Azurahanim Che Abdullah from UPM, and Dr Elena Azizan from UKM.

COP28 bertindak untuk menyokong pihak yang ‘rapuh’ kerana perubahan iklim
Persidangan Perubahan Iklim PBB (COP28) hari ini secara rasmi mendukung Deklarasi mengenai Iklim, Bantuan, Pemulih dan Keamanan di hari keempat pengajarannya.

Pelancong Jerman maut ditikam berhampiran Menara Eiffel di Paris
Seorang pelancong Jerman maut manakala dua lagi cedera dalam serangan berhampiran Menara Eiffel di ibu negara Perancis pada Sabtu malam.

KPKT akan bantu Johor selesai isu penempatan semula 10,301 rumah setinggan
Kementerian Pembangunan Kerajaan Tempatan (KPKT) akan membantu menyelesaikan isu penempatan semula 10,301 unit rumah setinggan, di Johor.

China nafi intip Parlimen Britain, gesa henti sebar maklumat palsu
China menafikan dakwaan Britain mengenai kemungkinan kes pengintipan di Parlimen London, lapor Agensi Berita Jerman ( dpa ).

Kelewatan perjalanan udara UK mungkin berterusan beberapa hari
Gangguan sistem kawalan udara United Kingdom (UK) memaksa ribuan penumpang syarikat penerbangan terkandas pada Isnin, dengan potensi gangguan berlanjutan.

Britain: Rishi Sunak umum hukum penjara seumur hidup bagi pembunuh kejam
Pesalah berbahaya yang melakukan pembunuhan paling kejam akan berdepan dengan hukuman penjara seumur hidup tanpa peluang dibebaskan.

COVID-19: Varian baharu dengan 'jumlah mutasi tinggi' ditemui di Britain
Varian COVID-19 baharu dengan "bilangan mutasi yang tinggi" telah dikesan di Britain.

Tentera Britain bergelut rekrut pakar keselamatan siber
Tentera Britain sedang bergelut untuk merekrut pakar keselamatan siber.

India, Britain catat kemajuan dalam rundingan perdagangan bebas
India dan Britain mencapai kemajuan dalam isu penting dalam rundingan perjanjian perdagangan bebas (FTA) dua hala.

Britain mahu Ukraine berterima kasih atas sumbangan senjata
Sama ada suka atau tidak, orang ramai mahu melihat rasa terima kasih daripada Ukraine kepada kerajaan Britain.

Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.

Lebih ramai pekerja di Eropah diberhentikan ekoran unjuran ekonomi lemah
Trend pengurangan tenaga kerja yang semakin meningkat sejak awal tahun ini memberi kesan kepada sekurang-kurangnya 140,000 individu.

Perjanjian perdagangan pertama UK pasca-Brexit dengan Australia, New Zealand berkuat kuasa
Ia adalah perjanjian perdagangan pertama pasca-Brexit yang berkuat kuasa dan dilaksanakan selepas UK, Australia dan New Zealand menyelesaikan proses ratifikasi domestik masing-masing.