PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today ordered former Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng to pay RM250,000 in general damages to former Baling Member of Parliament Datuk Seri Abdul Azeez Abdul Rahim for defamation in connection with the Penang undersea tunnel project.
A three-member panel comprising Justices Datuk Azizah Nawawi, Datuk Seri Mariana Yahya and Datuk Azimah Omar, in allowing Abdul Azeez's appeal, also ordered Lim as the respondent to pay RM70,000 in costs to Abdul Azeez.
Justice Azimah, when reading out the decision, said the lower court had erred in dismissing Abdul Azeez's suit against Lim and allowing Lim's defence of justification, fair comment and qualified privilege over his statement relating to Abdul Azeez.
Abdul Azeez was appealing against the Penang High Court's decision on Dec 11, 2020 in dismissing his defamation suit against Lim.
In March 2018, Abdul Azeez sued Lim, claiming that he had issued defamatory statements during a press conference at the Penang Chief Minister's Office on Feb 28, 2018, and during a Chinese New Year open house hosted by the Penang Development Corporation on the same day, linking Abdul Azeez to a payment of RM3 million as consultation fees from the developer of the undersea tunnel project.
Justice Azimah said the respondent did not take any step of his own to verify the information and he never sought any comment and response from the appellant for verification.
She further said the timing of Lim's issuance of the defamatory statement was too conveniently close to the 14th general election (GE14) in 2018.
"The respondent has acted for the benefit of his own political and personal agenda and interests," she added.
Justice Azimah also said that the respondent's statement went beyond seeking for the authorities to investigate the issue of alleged wrongdoing over the undersea tunnel project, and imputed that the appellant was involved in the matter.
"There is no evidence of the respondent reaching out to the appellant, there was no verification exercise. There was hastiness in the respondent publishing the defamatory statement," she said, adding that Lim did not issue the statement in good faith but made it for political interest.
According to the judge, the developer Consortium Zenith Construction Sdn Bhd had sent a notice of demand (NOD) to Abdul Azeez in February 2018 to recover the monies but retracted its NOD within a week, following Abdul Azeez's response to the company.
Justice Azimah said the respondent was not a 'common lay person' but a 'renowned and seasoned veteran' politician who was not a stranger to the litigation process.
"Thus, it should have been clear to him that a mere NOD is not evidence of guilt," she said, adding that there were no attempts by the respondent to verify the contents of the NOD.
Justice Azimah also said the court found that the respondent was not entitled to rely on the defence of justification and not entitled to rely on fair comment or qualified privilege.
During today's proceedings conducted via Zoom, Abdul Azeez was represented by lawyer Porres Royan and Craign Ho while Lim was represented by counsel Datuk N. Mureli and Felix Lim.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Aug 21 2023
Lim Guan Eng ordered to pay Datuk Seri Abdul Azeez Abdul Rahim in costs for defamation on the Penang undersea tunnel project. - BERNAMA/Astro AWANI/SHAHIR OMAR/Filepic
Muhammad Hakim Danish naik podium di GP Sepanyol
Pelumba muda negara Muhammad Hakim Danish Ramli mempamerkan peningkatan prestasi apabila menamatkan perlumbaan 2 Grand Prix (GP) Sepanyol bagi saingan Rookies Cup di kedudukan podium hari ini.
10 Berita Pilihan - (28 April 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
AWANI Ringkas: Inspektor ditahan kerja
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Ratu cantik Malaysia Harveen Kaur tawan Puncak Mera namun hilang jari akibat luka beku
Puncak Mera yang berketinggian 6,470 meter dari paras laut itu mampu memberi cabaran hebat meskipun kepada pendaki paling berpengalaman.
'Dek Wan' terus menyinar di Maghribi
Dek Wan mempamerkan larian bertenaga dengan mencatat masa 12.52 saat (s) untuk meninggalkan Taha Al Harrasi (12.65s) dari Oman.
Piala Thomas: Malaysia tempah slot ke suku akhir
Malaysia berjaya menempah slot ke suku akhir selepas menewaskan Algeria dengan kemenangan 5-0 dalam saingan Piala Thomas di Chengdu, China sebentar tadi.
Thailand: Enam muka baharu sertai Kabinet Srettha
Perdana Menteri Thailand Srettha Thavisin melantik enam menteri kabinet baharu.
Anwar bertemu PM Jordan, tekan kepentingan sokong pengiktirafan negara Palestin di PBB
Pada pertemuan itu, Perdana Menteri turut menekankan kepentingan memastikan Israel dipertanggungjawabkan terhadap kekejamannya di Palestin.
Lebih ramai atlet dijangka layak ke Paris 2024
Kontinjen Malaysia ke Sukan Olimpik Paris 2024 terus diperkuat dengan empat lagi atlet berjaya mengesahkan slot ke temasya terbesar dunia itu minggu ini, menjadikan sejumlah 10 atlet layak setakat ini
AWANI Ringkas: Polis sahkan Chegu Bard direman dua hari
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Projek terowong: SPRM jalankan siasatan khas terhadap Lim Guan Eng - Saksi
Saksi utama pendakwaan kes rasuah Lim Guan Eng memberitahu beliau tidak mendedahkan nama bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang itu semasa memberi keterangan kepada SPRM.
Kes rasuah: Nama Guan Eng timbul selepas kes Gnanaraja disiasat - Saksi
Seorang saksi mengaku di mahkamah bahawa nama Lim Guan Eng hanya ditimbulkan selepas lebih setahun kes rasuah membabitkan seorang ahli perniagaan di Shah Alam, disiasat.
Ahli Parlimen cadang kerajaan teliti impak cukai kepada rakyat
Kerajaan dicadang meneliti pelaksanaan cukai di dalam negara termasuk peningkatan kadar baharu cukai perkhidmatan yang berkemungkinan memberi kesan secara langsung kepada rakyat.
Saksi akui tidak beritahu SPRM RM2 juta untuk Lim Guan Eng
Menurut saksi, beliau tidak pernah menyatakan wang RM2 juta bertujuan diberikan kepada bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang itu.
Saksi tidak sebut nama Guan Eng dalam siasatan kes rasuah terowong dasar laut pada 2018
Seorang saksi utama pendakwaan mengakui bahawa beliau tidak pernah memberitahu SPRM pada 2018 bahawa rasuah RM2 juta ditujukan untuk bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang Lim Guan Eng.
RM247 juta kos penuh projek Gurney Bay - Chow
Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang Chow Kon Yeow menyangkal dakwaan bahawa Fasa 1 Gurney Bay melibatkan kos sebanyak RM247 juta.
Rasuah terowong dasar laut: Pernyataan saksi diserah kepada Guan Eng
Mahkamah Sesyen membenarkan sebahagian dokumen pernyataan saksi utama dalam perbicaraan kes rasuah projek terowong dasar laut diserahkan kepada pembelaan Guan Eng.
Guna air simpanan untuk minum dan masak, air tangki tidak sesuai - Guan Eng
Orang ramai perlu mengambil maklum mengenai air yang disediakan di tangki simpanan tetap tidak sesuai untuk tujuan minuman dan memasak.
Guan Eng cadang peruntukan semua ADUN k'jaan dinaik kepada RM800,000 setahun
Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Air Putih Lim Guan Eng memohon kepada kerajaan supaya peruntukan RM500,000 setahun untuk kesemua ADUN kerajaan ditambah kepada RM800,000, sama seperti di Selangor.
PDC tidak beri tanah kepada swasta untuk dibangunkan - Chow
Bank tanah perindustrian PDC terletak di lokasi strategik dan dapat dipasarkan kepada pelabur kategori industri digalakkan.