Racial politics in Malaysia will never go away regardless of the kind of efforts put in to change things, according to former Election Commission (EC) Chairman Tan Sri Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman.
The former civil servant was responding to a suggestion put forth today that voters should only be grouped according to age and gender and not by race.
“Politics of race in this country is so entrenched, it will go on and on till the end of the world,” Abdul Rashid told Astro Awani.
The idea to urge the EC to do away with voter data was mooted by Pas today.
“It is time for an overhaul, with the EC releasing voter breakdown according to age or sex as the official data distributed to the media and the public,” said PAS information chief Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man was quoted as saying.
However, Abdul Rashid clarified that the EC does not officially release such data and these racial statistics was mostly done by third parties.
“It is not something that the EC does. While I think that the party that proposed this has good intentions of creating a more inclusive Malaysia, I feel that even if such data was deliberately being taken out, the political parties will still continue to read voters in such a way,” said Abdul Rashid.
Meanwhile, a Bersih 2.0 leader said that it was a good idea to remove race from voter data, and this should also extend to any other official government data.
“I think we have to reduce the number of times we have to resort to racial classification. It would make Malaysia a society less preoccupied with race. We need to move away from that,” said Bersih steering committee member Andrew Khoo.
“In all the things that we do, the forms that we fill, I think we need to reconsider whether our race is necessary or not.”
He said that this would persuade or prompt political parties from not focusing on purely on race.
“Somebody has to take the lead to move away from race based classifying. We need to challenge people in their thinking. Is it proper to be so preoccupied with this.
“Government policies should reflect actual need, instead of perceived need based purely on racial profiling. if the EC can take the lead with doing away with race category, that would be a good start.”
For progressive Muslim think-tank Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF), the exclusion of statistics based on racial lines would mean little if there is little will to change.
IRF research fellow Ahmad Fuad Rahmat said that the problem of racism arises only when racist rhetoric is not curbed by the authorities.
“To me, it is not that big a deal what race a neighbourhood is. I think nowadays the demographic is changing nowadays, Malays don’t just vote for Malay candidates. People are smarter than that, we need to give Malaysians more credit.”
Ahmad Fuad stressed that those who spout hate speech, seditious and inflammatory statements must be punished.
“This proposal is a limited solution, certain parties would always say they have to represent the community that has particular cultural features.
“However, I do believe that people of influence and power in parties should refrain unconditionally of using race as the central factor.”
The GE13 results, which saw a sizable portion of the Chinese electoral swing towards the Opposition, was termed as a “Chinese tsunami” by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak. However, there has those who noted that there was Malays and Indians who voted for Pakatan Rakyat, especially in urban seats as well.
On Tuesday, Umno-owned daily Utusan Malaysia further put forth this racially skewed analysis by publishing an article with the headline“Apa lagi Cina mahu? (What else do the Chinese want?)”.
Utusan was criticised for the inflammatory headline but was defended by Najib, who indirectly blamed the DAP for misleading the Chinese into greater racial polarisation.
Teoh El Sen
Thu May 09 2013
Kerjasama bersepadu Persekutuan, Negeri selesai isu prasarana sekolah daif Sabah
Kerajaan Sabah akan terus menjalin kerjasama erat dengan kerajaan Persekutuan dalam usaha memberi suasana dan nafas baharu kepada prasarana sekolah di negeri itu.
Pantau Belanjawan: Tadbir Urus: ‘Spot check’ nilai prestasi penjawat awam
Semua ketua jabatan kerajaan perlu membuat semakan mengejut bagi memerhati pelaksanaan kerja kakitangan bawahan bagi memastikan tiada amalan negatif berlaku dalam jabatan masing-masing agar perkhidmatan awam kekal cekap, relevan dan berkesan. Apakah kaedah dan pendekatan terbaik untuk melaksanakan usaha ini?
Leftenan Muda Min Youn satu-satunya penuntut bangsa Cina tamat latihan Komando GGK 2024
Min Youn yang berasal dari Setapak, Kuala Lumpur itu merupakan graduan perakaunan daripada Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR).
Seorang maut, nahas dua kereta di Ipoh
Kemalangan melibatkan dua buah kereta iaitu jenis Honda City dan Peugeot.
Play Store kini benarkan muat turun dua aplikasi serentak
Berdasarkan laporan 9to5Google, ciri ini diberikan secara berperingkat kepada pengguna Android bermula dengan peranti\
Che'gu Bard mengaku tidak bersalah dua pertuduhan
Badrul Hisham mengaku tidak bersalah, selepas semua pertuduhan dibaca di hadapan Hakim, Siti Aminah Ghazali.
Tahanan PPA tekad jadikan kemahiran dalam “tirai besi” sebagai mata pencarian
Kehidupan di dalam tirai besi memberikan keinsafan kepada Fifi, Apit dan Bulat.
Ringgit susut berbanding dolar AS pada sesi awal
Pada 9 pagi, ringgit merosot kepada 4.7715/7810 berbanding mata wang Amerika Syarikat (AS) daripada 4.7650/7710 pada Jumaat.
Guna semula bangunan pawagam lama, bangkit suasana klasik
Ia bukan sahaja mampu menarik ramai pelancong tetapi juga mampu memulihara bangunan warisan yang masih elok dan ditatap oleh generasi kini.
Mesyuarat Khas WEF: PM Anwar jumpa 50 pemimpin industri, perniagaan global
PM yakin lebih banyak pelabur bernilai tinggi akan pilih Malaysia sebagai destinasi pelaburan.
Cadangan Reformasi Sistem Pilihan Raya untuk keadilan dalam pertandingan
Reformasi Sistem Pilihan Raya dicadangkan supaya semua parti politik di Malaysia boleh bertanding secara adil.
Tempoh penamaan calon perlu dipanjangkan - Pengerusi ERC
Beliau berkata perkara tersebut merupakan antara 15 agenda reformasi yang dikemukakan ERC bagi menambah baik sistem pilihan raya di negara ini supaya lebih telus dan tersusun.
Abdul Rashid tarik diri bertanding presiden KAFA
Dengan itu, EGM hari ini akan menyaksikan pertandingan dua penjuru antara Pengerusi Amanah Kelantan Wan Abdul Rahim Wan Abdullah dan ahli perniagaan Datuk Seri Amril Aiman Abdul Aziz.
Tun M akan kotakan janjinya - Tan Sri Rashid
Naib Presiden Bersatu, Tan Sri Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman berkata, Lim sepatutnya menaruh kepercayaan berdasarkan jaminan Dr Mahathir akan menyerahkan jawatan itu kepada Anwar.
Laporan Interim ERC diserah kepada PM tujuh bulan lagi
Penambahbaikan undang-undang itu katanya akan dilakukan pakar yang berkaitan dan laporan interin akan didedahkan kepada umum.
Dakwaan ada undi tidak percaya terhadap Tun Mahathir mungkin 'kerja' cybertroopers
Buat masa ini, semakin ramai orang sukakan Tun Dr Mahathir dan ramai mahu beliau kekal sebagai Perdana Menteri.
Pelaksanaan Akta Pembiayaan Politik diletak di bawah pengawasan ERC - SPR
Laporan pelaksanaan Akta Pembiayaan Politik diletakkan di bawah pengawasan ERC yang dipengerusikan Tan Sri Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman.
Itu pandangan peribadi Rashid - Tun Mahathir
Kenyataan Naib Presiden Pengerusi Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu), Tan Sri Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman yang mengarahkan pemberian kontrak secara kronisme adalah pandangan peribadi beliau.
Jangan polemik isu beri kontrak kepada ketua bahagian - Abu Bakar
Ahli Majlis Pimpinan Tertinggi Bersatu, Abu Bakar Yahya berkata, cadangan tersebut hanya pandangan peribadi dan bukan satu keputusan atau ketetapan yang dipersetujui sebulat suara parti itu.
'Rakyat Malaysia tidak bodoh' - Syed Saddiq kecam kenyataan Abdul Rashid
Syed Saddiq juga menegaskan pemimpin pemuda parti komponen Pakatan Harapan juga menentang usaha mengembalikan amalan tersebut.