KUALA LUMPUR: Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah has failed in his application to obtain leave from the High Court here today to file a counterclaim against the Inland Revenue Board's (IRB) demand that he pays income tax arrears amounting to RM9.41 million.
Judicial Commissioner (JC) Roz Mawar Rozain dismissed Muhammad Shafee's application after finding that the defendant's counterclaim does not arise from the recovery of taxes but from mala fide acts by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Agency (MACC) and the Attorney General's Chambers (AGC), which does not fall within the set scope of the rule prohibiting counterclaim.
"The court observed that the defendant's counterclaim was against parties like the MACC and the AGC, who are not part of this proceedings," she added.
The JC also said that whatever dissatisfaction over calculations of the taxes could be dealt with before Special Commissioners of Income Tax (SCIT).
She said that Muhammad Shafee's claim that tax assessments were "concocted mala fide" by MACC and the AGC can be dealt with another avenue.
The JC said that there was a slew of case laws which indicated that the whole scheme of tax law in Malaysia is that payment demanded must be paid notwithstanding appeals and that the principle of "pay first, talk later" is predominant.
"There may be appeals before SCIT but payments must be made or become debts due to the IRB of which they are legally empowered to collect the tax arrears," she said adding that Muhammad Shafee was not the first taxpayer who wished to file a counterclaim in these types of proceedings.
The JC also ordered a prominent lawyer to pay RM5,000 in costs to the government.
Meanwhile, the court fixed July 26 to hear summary judgment by the IRB on behalf of the government against Muhammad Shafee.
Muhammad Shafee filed the application in May 2021, on the grounds that, among others, the tax claim was an attack on him as a political victim in his capacity as a lawyer for former Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and was considered to be an UMNO lawyer even though he was not.
Muhammad Shafee claimed that on Aug 10, 2018, two days after the 1Malaysia Development Berhad charges were levelled on Najib, and after he issued a series of press statements critical of the Pakatan Harapan government, he was called in by the MACC to give a statement on the receipt of the RM9.5 million.
Following the statement to the MACC, Muhammad Shafee alleged that a meeting was held in September 2018 among the IRB, the MACC and AGC to discuss a plan of action to oppress and persecute him with the aim of discouraging him from acting as Najib's counsel.
On Sept 27, 2021, IRB requested that the suit against Muhammad Shafee be decided through summary judgement on the grounds that the defendant failed to pay the entire income tax arrears and the tax increase imposed on him amounting to RM9,414,708.32 within the stipulated period.
IRB which filed the suit on May 6, 2021, claimed that until now, the lawyer has still failed to pay the amount of income tax owed for the assessment years of 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2016 including the increase on the imposed sum.
On Oct 28 last year, the High Court acquitted and discharged Muhammad Shafee on two charges of receiving money from illegal activities amounting to RM9.5 million from Najib and two charges of making incorrect statements to the IRB.
However, the prosecution on Nov 1 last year filed an appeal against the court's decision.
Muhammad Shafee was represented by Datuk Seri Rajan Navaratnam and Muhammad Farhan Muhammad Shafee while IRB senior counsels Al-Hummidallah Idrus, Norzilah Abdul Hamid and Muhammad Faqrol Syazreen Mohd Ghause acted for the IRB.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Thu Apr 13 2023
The Judicial Commissioner said that Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee's claim that tax assessments were "concocted mala fide" by MACC and the AGC can be dealt with another avenue. - Astro AWANI/Hasimi Muhamad
NIOSH sedia beri khidmat nasihat depani cabaran perubahan iklim
NIOSH bersedia memberikan khidmat nasihat serta rundingan bagi membantu kerajaan, majikan dan pekerja menghadapi cabaran berkaitan perubahan iklim.
Malaysia negara pertama terima visa haji
Malaysia menjadi negara pertama yang menerima pengeluaran visa haji daripada Kementerian Haji dan Umrah Arab Saudi bagi jemaah musim haji 1445H/2024.
Menteri Indonesia bincang isu pekerja migran dengan rakan sejawat dari Malaysia
Fauziyah harap Steven akan membawa penambahbaikan kepada dasar berkaitan tenaga kerja Indonesia.
Pahang peruntuk RM1.5 juta bantuan tunai bakal jemaah haji
Sebanyak 1,588 jemaah haji Pahang menerima sumbangan 'duit poket' berjumlah RM750 seorang bagi membantu meringankan beban bakal haji dalam melakukan persiapan melaksanakan rukun Islam kelima itu.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Pengundi jangan mudah percaya taktik fitnah - Ramanan
Ramanan berkata pengundi perlu lebih berhati-hati, dan sentiasa menyemak fakta apabila mendengar kempen politik yang dilakukan pihak lawan.
KEDA berhasrat tanam padi wangi, padi huma tahun ini
Lembaga Kemajuan Wilayah Kedah (KEDA) berhasrat membangunkan tanaman padi wangi dan padi huma di beberapa kawasan pertanian dalam wilayahnya, tahun ini.
Mesyuarat perundingan Enam Pihak Arab bincangkan perkembangan di Gaza
Mesyuarat perundingan Jawatankuasa Enam Pihak Arab itu membincangkan perkembangan serangan Israel ke atas Semenanjung Gaza.
Chegubard didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen KL esok - Peguam
Badrul Hisham Shaharin atau dikenali Chegubard akan didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen Kuala Lumpur esok atas pertuduhan memfitnah dan menghasut.
Pulau Pinang, kerajaan pusat bekerjasama tarik pelaburan semikonduktor
Kerajaan Pulau Pinang akan bekerjasama dengan Kerajaan Persekutuan untuk meneruskan usaha menarik pelaburan dalam sektor semikonduktor, termasuk segmen reka bentuk litar bersepadu (IC) di negeri itu.
Rakyat Malaysia di Jordan jadi duta produk PMKS negara
Menteri Pembangunan Usahawan dan Koperasi Datuk Ewon Benedick menyarankan rakyat Malaysia yang menetap di Jordan supaya memainkan peranan sebagai “duta” untuk mempromosikan produk perusahaan mikro kecil dan sederhana (PMKS) SERTA koperasi negara.
1MDB: Muhammad Shafee ditegur hakim kerana bersikap 'keterlaluan'
Ketua peguam bela yang mewakili Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak ditegur apabila dilihat menyerang kredibiliti pengawai penyiasat Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) ketika perbicaraan.
Keputusan permohonan Najib mulakan semakan kehakiman cabar kewujudan Titah Adendum 5 Jun
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur menetapkan 5 Jun untuk memutuskan permohonan kebenaran semakan kehakiman difailkan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak bagi mencabar kewujudan perintah tambahan beliau.
Ada seorang saksi penting dijangka sokong permohonan Najib untuk tahanan di rumah - Shafee
Seorang saksi penting dijangka memfailkan afidavit bagi menyokong permohonan kebenaran Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak untuk memulakan semakan kehakiman.
Shafee alami palpitasi, perbicaraan kes 1MDB Najib tangguh
Perbicaraan Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak berhubung kes penyelewengan RM2.3 bilion dana 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) di Mahkamah Tinggi ditangguhkan hari ini.
Najib akan mohon pengampunan kali kedua - Shafee
Peguamnya Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah memaklumkan permohonan itu dibuat disebabkan anak guamnya tidak mendapat keadilan ketika perbicaraan dan proses Lembaga Pengampunan.
Tunggakan cukai: Muhammad Shafee perlu bayar RM5.5 juta kepada LHDN
Peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah diperintahkan oleh Mahkamah Tinggi supaya membayar tunggakan cukai pendapatan lebih RM5.5 juta kepada Lembaga Hasil Dalam Negeri (LHDN).
LHDN peroleh penghakiman terus kes tunggakan cukai Muhammad Shafee
Mahkamah Tinggi membenarkan permohonan LHDN untuk memasukkan penghakiman terus terhadap peguam Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah berkaitan kes tunggakan cukai.
Pendakwaan tarik balik rayuan, keputusan lepas dan bebas Shafee kekal
Penarikan balik rayuan itu bermakna pembebasan Muhammad Shafee dalam keempat-empat kes itu kekal.
Tunggakan cukai pendapatan RM9.41 juta: Shafee, LHDN akan selesai kes
Muhammad Shafee dan LHDN memberitahu Mahkamah Tinggi bahawa, kes tuntutan tunggakan cukai pendapatan, berada dalam proses penyelesaian.
Najib tidak bekerjasama selepas didakwa - Pegawai penyiasat 1MDB
Datuk Seri Najib Razak dikatakan tidak memberi kerjasama ketika disoal siasat berhubung penyelewengan dana 1MDB.