The Conditional Movement Control Order (CMCO) to fight the COVID-19 pandemic imposed by the federal government, which entered its eighth day today, have so far received mixed reactions from state governments, with some embracing it fully and others having reservations.
The CMCO was due to end on May 12 but Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin announced at 2 pm yesterday that it is necessary to extend it until June 9.
However, according to legal consultant Datuk Dr Gurdial Singh Nijar, under the constitution, all state governments must comply with federal laws and must not do anything that may impair or oppose a particular federal order.
In a Bernama TV interview Saturday, Gurdial said under the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988, during this COVID-19 pandemic, the federal government is the only enforcing agency or authority that can enforce this law and not the state governments.
“Restaurants, food courts, hawker stalls, food stalls, food trucks can be open for business, this is the governing law that governs throughout the country, this is what we call a federal law under the constitution.
"Once there is a federal law, then all states must obey and if there is any conflict between state laws and federal law, then federal laws prevail.
“But there is still confusion in certain sates where most restaurants are still closed, food trucks and food stalls are not allowed to operate except for deliveries, this confusion is due to fear of violation of regulations,” he said.
Gurdial said this confusion should be clarified and cleared by the federal government so that the federal order is adhered to and honoured by all state governments.
Apart from that, he pointed out that under the constitution, local government laws can only be used in licensing of businesses premises and specifically deals with certain sanitary and health conditions that relate to the running of businesses such as restaurants.
“If there are rats or rodents or unsanitary conditions, then they (state authorities) can take action, other than that, with regards to infectious diseases or COVID-19, federal laws must be applied and there is no excuse for state governments to seek to contradict the CMCO,” he added.
Under the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988, the federal government imposed the Movement Control Order (MCO) to flatten the curve of COVID-19 transmission. It was to end on May 12 but because it was hugely successful, was loosened to the CMCO on May 4.
The prime minister, in his address on the COVID-19 situation today that was aired over national television, said the CMCO was still necessary to fight the pandemic.
Unlike the MCO which strictly restricts movement of people and limits operations to only essential services, the CMCO has now loosened up the economic sector, thus enabling people to return to work with all almost economic sectors allowed to reopen.
Bernama
Sun May 10 2020
If there is any conflict between state laws and federal law, then federal laws prevail, says Datuk Dr Gurdial Singh Nijar. Photo/FILE
Inisiatif IHH Healthcare lancar pemasangan panel solar wajar jadi contoh - Fadillah Yusof
IHH Healthcare Malaysia mencatatkan pencapaian baharu dengan melancarkan inisiatif pemasangan panel solar di seluruh rangkaian hospitalnya sekali gus menjadikannya pelopor.
Che'gu Bard akan didakwa di Johor Bahru esok
Che'gu Bard berkata, ia dipercayai berhubung kenyataannya mengenai isu kasino di Forest City, Johor.
Ahmad Zahid ucap tahniah kepada Farah Ain
Ahmad Zahid mengucapkan tahniah kepada atlet boling padang Nor Farah Ain Abdullah yang muncul juara pada Kejohanan Boling Padang Dalam Dewan Dunia 2024.
Raih RM31 juta sejak ditayangkan! Sheriff kini filem no. 1 di Malaysia
Berita gembira ini turut disokong oleh abang Syafiq, Syamsul Yusof yang turut bangga dengan kejayaan naskhah yang dihasilkan adiknya.
Letupan bom Sungai Golok: PDRM tingkat kawalan keselamatan sempadan Malaysia-Thailand
PDRM mempertingkatkan kawalan keselamatan di sempadan Malaysia-Thailand susulan insiden letupan bom dan bunyi tembakan di Sungai Golok.
Pemain ragbi meninggal dunia selepas perlawanan pasukan pilihan MB Kedah
Seorang bekas pemain Sukma Kedah meninggal dunia selepas menyertai perlawanan pertunjukan pasukan pilihan Menteri Besar Kedah pada Ahad.
OCC: Masih banyak usaha perlu dibuat dalam isu hak kanak-kanak
Masih banyak yang perlu dilakukan kerana Malaysia masih ketinggalan berbanding negara lain dalam menangani isu penderaan dan masalah sosial melibatkan kanak-kanak.
iPad Pro mungkin dijana dengan cip Apple M4 terbaharu, fokus ciri AI
Cip Apple M4 dijangka memfokuskan kepada keupayaan enjin neural yang disertakan bersama dengannya membolehkan ia menawarkan ciri AI yang lebih baik.
Lebih 840,000 permohonan untuk London Marathon 2025 pecah rekod dunia
Jumlah permohonan untuk menyertai larian TCS London Marathon tahun depan telah memecahkan rekod dunia.
WEF: Anwar jumpa 50 pemimpin industri & perniagaan, yakin pelabur bernilai tinggi pilih Malaysia
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menzahirkan keyakinan lebih banyak pelabur bernilai tinggi akan memilih Malaysia sebagai destinasi pelaburan mengikut jejak langkah syarikat-syarikat gergasi seperti Tesla, AWS, Infineon dan Nvidia.
Bekas Ketua Pengarang Bernama, Datuk Yong Soo Heong dilantik Presiden MPI
Bekas Ketua Pengarang Pertubuhan Berita Nasional Malaysia (Bernama) Datuk Yong Soo Heong dilantik sebagai Presiden Institut Akhbar Malaysia (MPI).
Pemergian Abdul Rahman @ Roger kehilangan besar dunia kewartawanan negara
Rakan seperjuangan sifatkan Allahyarham Roger seorang sahabat yang sukar dicari ganti atas kesanggupannya menghulurkan bantuan kepada rakan dan teman sekerja.
Bernama, RTM, JaPen perlu perkukuh kerjasama rangka strategi tangkis berita palsu
Bernama, RTM dan JaPen perlu memperkukuhkan kerjasama dalam merangka strategi bagi menangkis berita palsu.
Tiada kebebasan mutlak, wartawan, organisasi media harus terus tingkat kualiti
Walaupun tidak wujud kebebasan mutlak dalam industri media, wartawan dan organisasi media harus terus meningkatkan kualiti pelaporan berita mereka.
Bekas Pengarang Urusan Bernama meninggal dunia
Arwah yang menghidap pelbagai penyakit, menghembuskan nafas terakhir kira-kira pukul 5.48 pagi di klia2.
Personaliti TV Astro AWANI Essan Yahya akhiri zaman bujang
Personaliti Astro AWANI Salehuddin Yahya selamat diijab kabul dengan buah hatinya, Nurul Syaza Mohd Sahaib dengan sekali lafaz di Pejabat Agama Daerah Seberang Perai Selatan pada Khamis.
Bernama perjelas isu infografik PKP3 tular
Ketua Pengarang Bernama Abdul Rahman Ahmad menasihati orang ramai agar memeriksa fakta yang mereka temukan di media sosial.
Tiada 'wahyu', Bernama buat liputan Perhimpunan Agung UMNO secara seimbang
Dakwaan bahawa Pertubuhan Berita Nasional Malaysia (BERNAMA) kononnya menerima 'wahyu' untuk liputan Perhimpunan Agung UMNO (PAU) 2020 yang berlangsung hari ini dan esok, adalah tidak benar.
Bernama boleh bantu artis terkesan COVID-19, kata Ras Adiba
Artis yang berdepan kesukaran akibat hilang punca pendapatan atau masalah kesihatan perlu diberi perhatian sebagai tanda menghargai sumbangan mereka kepada dunia seni negara.
Temu bual eksklusif Muhyiddin Yassin malam ini
Perdana Menteri akan mengupas perincian Belanjawan 2021 serta isu-isu semasa.